Wind farm in the Isthmus of Tehuantepec. A wind farm in the Isthmus of Tehuantepec.

Court orders halt to Juchitán wind farm

Local community was not consulted, court finds, stopping US $1.2-billion project

The Supreme Court ruled yesterday that a wind farm project in Oaxaca must be halted because the process to approve it violated the rights of the local indigenous community.

ADVERTISEMENT

Judges from Mexico’s highest court unanimously decided to grant an amparo, or injunction, to members of the Zapotec community in Juchitán on the grounds that they hadn’t been consulted or given their permission or authorization for the project to go ahead on their land.

A district court in Salinas Cruz, Oaxaca previously ruled against a similar injunction request in June 2016.

The plaintiffs also argued that the project being built by Energía Eólica del Sur could cause significant environmental damage that would directly affect the local community.

An official groundbreaking ceremony was held in November at the site of the project, where state Governor Alejandro Murat celebrated its having earned the approval of the local communities in accordance with international treaty obligations.

The company plans to build 132 wind turbines on 5,300 hectares of land in the Isthmus of Tehuantepec region, one of Mexico’s windiest. The Japanese firm Mitsubishi is an investor in the US $1.2-billion farm, which was 22% complete in November.

The case against the project was supported by a document signed by 17 national and international human rights organizations that was presented to the court in September.

ADVERTISEMENT

The document also argued that the law — and the indigenous community’s rights — had been violated because they were not consulted prior to government authorization of the project or the commencement of work.

In addition, it said that implementing a consultation process after the project had already been approved was not compatible with convention 169 of the International Labour Organization, which stipulates rights as they apply to indigenous and tribal peoples.

“It concerns us that the process of consultation with indigenous peoples and communities in Mexico is treated by authorities as a mere procedure that puts substantive issues linked to land rights and the free determination of the people to the side,” the document said.

“A true consultation process should seek sincere and meaningful dialogue with the communities,” it continued.

In handing down its decision, the court recognized their grievances and cited the indigenous community’s “right to prior, free and informed consultation” as justification for its ruling.

Source: Milenio (sp), NVI Noticias (sp)

Stories from our archives that you might enjoy

  • DragonTat2

    Were it to be approved, locals should get first dibs on the jobs.

  • HandyMan

    Ha ha.

  • WestCoastHwy

    Indigenous community, Mexico’s still playing ” Cowboys and Indians”. As I constantly say to Mexicans, either form Indigenous Reservations and stop the Ejido madness or continue with the never ending Indian Probate! Not that viral infected blankets ever worked.

  • WorldCommenter

    Why doesn’t the Mexican Court rule against the Mexican regulators that approved the facility without proper procedures? If the Governor of the Mexican State thought that proper consultations had taken place and Mexican State and Federal regulators had approved the project, they should be the ones “at fault”. Guess the final lesson is do not build anything in Mexico, since their own government does not know what the required approvals are.

FreeCurrencyRates.com
ADVERTISEMENT