Unhappy fishermen in San Felipe on Thursday. Unhappy fishermen in San Felipe on Thursday.

Fishermen protest in Sonora, Baja California

Gillnet ban, shrimp boycott anger fishermen in upper Sea of Cortés

Fishermen in the upper Sea of Cortés, caught in the middle of efforts to protect a species of porpoise that is on the verge of extinction, faced off against environmentalists this week, protesting their presence in the area and their support for a boycott of Mexican shrimp.


Protests in Golfo de Santa Clara, Sonora, and San Felipe, Baja California, were triggered by a call two weeks ago by United States conservation organizations for the shrimp boycott, followed by a proposal last week from Mexican officials to shut down gillnet fishing in the region.

What is now “a pressure cooker,” said area fishermen, threatens to become a bomb because the gillnet ban would represent the final blow for local communities.

The ban, which would take effect April 11, is the federal fisheries secretariat’s answer to the expiry of a two-year strategy to protect the vaquita porpoise. The strategy has not been successful: the vaquita population has declined from 90 to 30 during that period, according to estimates.

The situation heated up on Thursday when fishermen and local residents boarded dozens of fishboats with the intention of “neutralizing” two vessels operated by the U.S.-based Sea Shepherd Conservation Society.

Fishermen’s spokesman Antonio Sunshine Rodríguez Peña said their intention was to contain the vessels within a “security ring” because their presence in the area was “illegal.”

“We know they don’t have permission from the Communications and Transportation Secretariat (SCT) or from Immigration or Conapesca (the National Aquaculture and Fisheries Commission) to perform studies in Mexico,” he charged.


“The big question is why are they allowed to violate the law, the rules” when fishermen must comply 100% with the law.

The Sea Shepherd vessels, the Sam Simon and the Farley Mowat, left the area later to avoid a confrontation.

But the organization called the protesters “vaquita murderers” in a Facebook post and accused Rodríguez, described as “the ringleader of the poachers,” of threatening to burn the ships.

Captain Oona Isabelle Layolle, head of Sea Shepherd’s Operation Milagro III, a surveillance campaign designed to monitor illegal fishing, said the two vessels will be soon joined by a third ship.

Sea Shepherd began surveillance nearly two years ago after signing an agreement with the Mexican government, which said the accord would provide “more eyes on the sea.”

A group of seven environmentalist organizations based in Mexico, including Greenpeace México and Cemda, the Mexican Center for Environmental Law, endorsed the actions undertaken by Sea Shepherd and asked the government to protect its crew because they had allegedly been threatened by local fishermen.

The NGOs also demanded that authorities dismantle the illegal market for totoaba, which they claimed persists despite restrictions on fishing in the area.

The fishermen’s other concern is the shrimp boycott, which is a strategy designed to pressure the Mexican government to adopt stringent measures to protect the vaquita. One measure, announced earlier this year, is to capture the remaining vaquitas and encourage them to breed in captivity.

Source: Reforma (sp), Animal Político (sp), Televisa (sp)

Stories from our archives that you might enjoy

  • K. Chris C.

    Give a man a fish, and he’ll eat for a day. Teach a man to fish, and he’ll eat his entire lifetime, unless government, egged on by foreign interlopers, robs him of the ability to fish.”

    They should send that Sea Shepard boat to the bottom, as what is a Canadian founded US based organization doing down in Mexico but imposing societal chaos and starvation on poor coastal inhabitants?! Much like the prototypical bully they, prey upon the weak and vulnerable.

    An American citizen, not US subject.

    • Brenda Rapp Sabo

      You should educate yourself more on the situation…just saying.

    • Gary Jennings

      You do understand a few of the fish are going extinct due to over fishing… the day will come when there are no fish… then what. Do no blame people trying to help save the last 100 fish… when their gone… gone for ever.

    • rainycoastguy

      For 20 year the price of shrimp was around 80 pesos a kilo. Now it is 3 to 400 and most comes from farms around Mazatlan. 10 years ago the word was out that fish stocks were declining fast but nothing was done. A few people trying to save the last remaining stocks should be lauded, not denigrated. 7.5 billion people on this planet is 6.5 billion too many but I doubt that you’d agree. When the line ups for human flesh as a food source start – I expect to see you up at the front.

    • Sea Shepherd is taking no part in the boycott of shrimp, nor are we targeting legal fishing only poaching and illegal fishing nets. The idea is to save the Vaquita from extinction and the endangered Totoaba. Sea Shepherd is a Global movement made up of people all over the world including Mexico. Poaching is the legal fisherman’s enemy not Sea Shepherd.

  • Paul Watson

    To clear up a few inaccuracies I must point out that Sea Shepherd is not part of nor does Sea Shepherd support the boycott of Mexican shrimp, in fact we view the boycott as irresponsible especially so since we are the only group with a presence and thus a target for the fishermen. Secondly despite what Rodriguez is saying, Sea Shepherd does have a written contract to be in the Sea of Cortez and Sea Shepherd has authorization from the Mexican government to locate and confiscate illegal nets. Thirdly, Sea Shepherd is not a U.S. based organization. Sea Shepherd is in 40 countries and registered in Mexico and international HQ is in Amsterdam. The ships in the Sea of Cortez are Dutch with French captains. The leader of the campaign is French and Colombian. Sea Shepherd is not anti-fishermen, we are anti poaching.