Earthquake damage in southern Mexico. Earthquake damage in southern Mexico. Reuters/Jorge Luis Plata

Earthquakes expose MX’s deep inequality

Oaxaca and Chiapas, Mexico’s two poorest states, took the harshest blow

Early in the morning on September 16, 1810, priest Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla rang the bell of his church in the small town of Dolores, near Guanajuato, Mexico. His parishioners gathered round, and he urged them to revolt against Spain’s two-year-old Napoleonic government.


Hidalgo’s call to arms, which later became known later as the Grito de Dolores (Cry of Dolores), triggered the Mexican War of Independence. Every September 15, the president of Mexico takes to the balcony of the National Palace in Mexico City to reenact it.

This year, just a week before Independence Day, a historic earthquake struck Mexico’s southern coast, killing nearly 100 people. So President Enrique Peña Nieto added a poignant element to his Grito by including in the incantation a reference to the impoverished states that were most devastated by the quake, crying “Long live the solidarity of Mexicans with Chiapas and Oaxaca!”

It was a nice twist on tradition, but these two states will need more than expressions of solidarity to recover. The 8.2-magnitude quake is the strongest Mexico has experienced in 100 years, surpassing even the September 19, 1985 earthquake that killed an estimated 40,000 people in and around Mexico City.

It was also significantly more powerful than the 7.1-magnitude earthquake that killed upwards of 200 people in and around Mexico’s capital yesterday.

This latest quake shook Mexico City 32 years to the day after the 1985 “big one.” I was 11 years old when the quake hit, and I recall the government of president Miguel de la Madrid reacting with what can only be described as criminal apathy: in the first days after the disaster he prevented the Army from rescuing victims and rejected international aid.

The people of Mexico City, however, took to the streets, distributing food, water and blankets among those who needed them and digging neighbors free from the rubble with their bare hands.


This time around, the death toll is significantly lower than it was in 1985: 78 fatalities in Oaxaca, 16 in Chiapas and four in Tabasco for the first earthquake, and more than 220 for the second. In part, this reflects improvements in building regulations since 1985 and the creation of both a Mexican Seismic Alert System and a National Civil Protection System.

Still, the damages are daunting. Scores of buildings in Mexico City have suffered catastrophic damage.

But it was Oaxaca and Chiapas – Mexico’s two poorest states – that took the harshest blow. More than 2,500 schools have been severely harmed and 85,000 houses have been affected – more than 17,000 of them beyond repair.

Poverty makes these disaster impacts worse in the south. On average, 46% of Mexican households live in poverty. But 70% of Oaxaca’s population earns less than what’s needed to satisfy basic family needs, according to the government agency Coneval, and 77% of those in Chiapas.

In both states, the lowest-income families make as little as 37 pesos (US $2) per day, less than half the the Mexican minimum wage, which is 80.04 pesos, or around $4.50 a day.

The World Bank lists Mexico as the 15th most powerful economy in the world, but its wealth has not trickled down to the southern states.

That fact has left many on the ground wondering whether the 16 billion Mexican pesos ($901 million) in federal disaster assistance being offered to 283 municipalities in Oaxaca and 97 in Chiapas will get to where it needs to go.

Unequal development in Mexico is an ongoing challenge. A recent report by the Bank of México showed that during the second trimester of 2017, the Mexican economy grew in the north (0.9%), the center-north (1.2%) and central zones (0.7%), home to such powerhouse cities as Monterrey, Guadalajara and Mexico City, but contracted over 1% in the rural south.

If there’s a silver lining to these twin earthquakes, it’s that the post-disaster recovery analyses have finally shed some light on the historical neglect of Chiapas and Oaxaca, together home to around nine million Mexicans.

It is not incidental that many of those residents are of indigenous descent. Upwards of 40% of Mexico’s indigenous peoples live in the southern states of Oaxaca, Chiapas and Yucatán.

Their economic exclusion dates back to the colonial era. In 1813, a Chiapas priest, Mariano Robles Domínguez de Mazariegos, testified in Spain to the “violent humiliations” suffered by the indigenous inhabitants of Chiapas who, he said, lived a life of “agitation and continuous terror and distress” because they were treated with such “contempt and hatred.”

More than 200 years later, on New Year’s Day 1994, the Zapatistas, whose ranks consist of largely of poor Mayans from Chiapas, used similar words to justify an indigenous rebellion against the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which had just been signed.

Condemning NAFTA as a death sentence for traditional agricultural methods still practiced on collectively owned indigenous lands, the First Declaration of the Lacandona Jungle asserted that Chiapas’ rural population had “nothing” — “no land, no work, no health care, no food nor education” – not even a roof over their heads.

As the recent earthquake reveals, the plight of indigenous Mexicans has not improved markedly over the past 200 years. Their homes offered tenuous shelter from the quake at at best, and their food supplies, long delicate, are now running short.

Mexico is and always will be a land of earthquakes. Pre-Columbian records report seismic activity attributed to the wrath of gods said to be unhappy about the state of human affairs.

Today, quakes still unearth the best and the worst in Mexico.

It’s not clear that Peña Nieto, whose government is dogged by scandals and wildly public corruption, can make use of this crisis to bring social change to Oaxaca and Chiapas.

Other politicians are falling short of this high bar, too. In a Facebook video, the wife of Chiapas Governor Manuel Velasco, a member of Peña Nieto’s inner circle, toured a ruined Chiapas home to show the administration “is helping” but lamented her “tousled” hair.

The populace, at least, is coming to its own assistance. Right after the quake in Mexico City, people formed veritable factory lines of diggers to excavate their buried neighbors and loaned out bicycles so stranded colleagues could make their way home.

Residents of Mexico’s southern region have also showed the country what resilience looks like, even in the face of overwhelming historic odds. In the town of Juchitán, Oaxaca, where the historic town hall pancaked after the earthquake, a man picked up a Mexican flag that had previously decorated its facade, shook off the dust and then, in an act that touched millions, placed it atop the debris.The Conversation

Luis Gómez Romero is a senior lecturer in human rights, constitutional law and legal theory at the University of Wollongong. This article was originally published on The Conversation.

Stories from our archives that you might enjoy

  • Güerito

    On his first tour of Chiapas after the quake, EPN was caught on video saying to an aide, “Wow, I’m surprised there are so many white people down here…”

    Governor Manuel Velasco looks like a German midget and his telenovela wife looks like a Bavarian beer maid.

  • Isaac Maxwell

    how NOT to help with the ongoing crisis in mexico; write a politicizing overly long comment about it.

    twitter for the semi-intelligent

    • Evita

      Indeed. The earthquakes that struck Mexico this month are NOTHING compared to the extensive murders, kidnappings of school girls who are then raped, forced to prostitution, or murdered, and many other crimes the narco cartels are doing.

      That country has become in some parts very, very dangerous, even to the point that it is not safe to walk in the streets, or even drive, or have a business such as grocery store, because you can be attacked, kidnapped, robbed, murdered.
      There is soooo much evil running wild around this country, though beatiful, yet has become like a hell.
      And you see, their president, says NOTHING, for fear to spook (correctly guessing) foreign investors. So, Silence, “no pasa nada”, crimes and horrendous murders, young girls disappearing and their parents crying for their daughters, so young, gone and never to come back.
      Can you imagine living like that? and your government hiding everything, all corruption, all crimes, Justice, where is the justice for the victims? Nowhere!! yet, rotten evil members of human rights screaming and accusing the government for the rights of the murderers not being respected!!!!
      The world is upside down in Mexico; where many criminals, devoid of all human decency, behave like worst than brainless beasts, think they are doing something good. Immorality. Extensive immorality exists among the vast majority of mexicans. They are impregnated with the culture of corruption, of “mordida”, of lying, the dirtiness is reflected in how they speak, with filthy language.
      When Mexico will be a safe country, where Justice is done, and the Law is respected? Only God Almighty knows if that will ever be possible.

      • DeplorableVI

        Mexicans don’t respect law in the United States and I don’t soon expect them to respect law in Mexico. Build that wall. Strong and tall.

        • Joshua Rodriguez

          Why are you even on here if your a trump supporter just go join breitbart don’t hate on mexico its not the peoples fault it our corrupt government.

          • ttboy2004

            Mexicans are to lazy to correct the ills of the society and government as long as the money from the north nothing will change no incentive to do so

  • Commander Barkfeather

    As a citizen of the United States, who happens to live in Mexico, I must commend Sr. Gomez Romero for his insightful article, and express my deep humiliation at the responses it has evoked, thus far. To summarize those responses, it would seem that the true reason for recent disasters in Mexico, is due to corruption, moral failure, bad hygiene, and “filthy language,” and the only solution for Mexico’s miseries, is to build a wall, “strong and tall,” and isolate (perhaps “segregate” would be a better word) the great unwashed, morally degenerate, inherently evil, brown skinned, indigenous nativos. This is not the first time this solution has been suggested. In Warsaw, it was called the “ghetto.” The ghetto did not produce manicured lawns, straight teeth, or a greater appreciation for western style capitalism. Instead it produced the single most evil for evil’s sake, act of man’s inhumanity to his fellow man in a history replete with similar attempts. I take solace from the myopic views of my compatriots with the words of another Catholic priest, Dom Helder Camara, “When I feed the poor, they call me a saint, but when I ask why the poor are hungry, they call me a communist.”

  • DeplorableVI

    They say for every one dollar of donated aid money less than two cents will make it to the needy. Corruption is expensive.