Nashville museum returns over 200 artifacts to Mexico

A museum in Nashville, Tennessee, will soon be repatriating 248 pre-Columbian artifacts originally from western Mexico.

The Parthenon museum and Nashville’s Metro Parks and Recreation department worked with Mexico’s Consulate in Atlanta, Georgia, to arrange for the return of the artifacts that include small adornments, zoomorphic images, ceramic pots, musical instruments and hand tools.

The pieces will be delivered to the Institute of Anthropology and History Museum (INAH) in Mexico City later this summer, the museum explained in a press release.

The Nashville Metropolitan Council on May 7 passed an ordinance change that legally entitled The Parthenon museum to remove the pre-Columbian artifacts from its collection and return them to their country of origin.

“For Metro Parks, the repatriation of these artifacts is a cultural obligation as well as a moral responsibility,” said Metro Parks Director Monique Horton Odom. “These artifacts have value and meaning to the people of Mexico and should be housed where they will have a dynamic impact on understanding the people and culture of the past.”

How the artifacts ended up in Nashville

The Parthenon received the pre-Columbian artifacts in question in the 1960s and 1970s, as donations from Dr. John L. Montgomery and Edgar York.

Rich Montgomery, the son of Dr. Montgomery, told The Associated Press how his father came to donate the artifacts to the Nashville museum. He said he and his brother scoured the hills and villages in the state of Colima in the 1960s looking for pottery and figurines as part of a scheme to lower income taxes via museum donations.

Montgomery insists they did not smuggle the artifacts. “We would show this stuff to the Mexican authorities as we left the country, and those guys could care less about it. And when we came into the U.S., we would show it to the customs people here on this side.”

Mexico did not enforce its antiquities laws very evenly back then, admits Javier Díaz de León, the Mexican consul general in Atlanta who worked with the Nashville Parthenon on the repatriation.

Two women take a selfie in front of colorful multi-media art in a Nashville museumTwo women take a selfie in front of colorful multi-media art with Mexican motifs in a Nashville museum.
The exhibit “Repatriation and Its Impact” included work by Michoacán artist José Vera González alongside the artifacts, prior to their repatriation to Mexico. (Victoria Metzger/Nashville Parthenon)

A growing awareness of artifacts’ cultural value

Díaz de León had nothing but praise for the museum and he credits the repatriation effort to the public becoming more aware of the ethical issues of keeping artifacts taken from other countries.

“It’s a greater conscience,” Díaz de León said. “People come to us … saying, ‘I got this. It came into our hands. But we don’t think we should have it. We think it belongs to the Mexican people.’”

As part of the deaccession and repatriation process, the Parthenon curated an exhibition entitled “Repatriation and Its Impact” that discussed the effects of cultural looting in the art and antiquities trade. The exhibit closed on Sunday.

With reports from The Associated Press, NPR and The Tennessean

1 COMMENT

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Mexico City Stadium

Mexico City’s box seat owners kept their seats at the World Cup — but they’ll pay dearly to eat in them

0
If they want to eat and drink, box owners will be forced to purchase "hospitality packages" directly from FIFA, which reportedly cost US $75,000 for 12 people for all five World Cup matches at Mexico City Stadium.
estela de luz protest

Activists climb a Mexico City monument to proclaim that human rights are ‘also in play’

1
The choice of the phrase "in play" (en juego) in reference to human rights was seemingly meant to call attention to how little notice they are getting compared to the World Cup games.
The heightened security in and around Mexico City's Historic Center, due to threats of protests and the construction of the FIFA Fan Festival in the Zócalo, is frustrating business owners, who claim there is no foot traffic.

At least 7 protest marches plan to descend on Mexico City Stadium during World Cup opener

1
Protesters — who include searching mothers, teachers, retirees, healthcare workers, farmers, anti-gentrification activists and transportation workers — are expected to arrive at the stadium just as the Mexico vs. South Africa match is starting.
BETA Version - Powered by Perplexity