Court rules against dismissed employee over swastika tattoo

The Supreme Court has refused to grant constitutional protection to a man who demanded compensation from a former employer who fired him for displaying a swastika tattoo.

The court voted unanimously on Wednesday to uphold the ruling of presiding judge Norma Piña Hernández, who determined that in today’s cultural environment, the swastika “represents [anti-Semitic] hate speech.”

Court documents state that the man’s coworkers, the majority of them Jewish, “felt offended, attacked or abused” from his first day on the job.

Also Jewish, the man’s boss stated he had “clearly defined convictions on the issue.”

The company had asked the man to cover or remove the tattoo in order to keep his job as invoice manager, but he refused.

“His contract was terminated, with severance, for which the complainant signed the respective resignation and settlement,” court documents indicated.

The man immediately filed a lawsuit against the company for moral damages, with the argument that he had been the victim of discrimination.

He claimed it had affected “legal assets of his personality,” having caused “inconvenience, confusion, annoyance and generally hurt his feelings.”

The company maintained that the Nazi symbol “represented anti-Semitic expression that signified hate and defeat for the Jewish community, and that such an image affected the dignity of the company’s employees and managers who belong to that community.”

Judge Piña ruled in favor of the company, rejecting the discrimination argument, calling the swastika an “apologia of hate.”

“The measures taken by the company in the name of human dignity and the security of its employees and managers were valid, reasonable and proportional,” read her ruling. “As such, they cannot constitute an act of discrimination against the complainant. Therefore, they do not define a legal right to compensation for moral damages.”

Source: Milenio (sp)

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
senate chambers

Mexican Senate passes bill to limit, and sometimes prohibit, cash payments

5
The Digital Economy Law for Digital and Electronic Payments could conceivably become law this week, though it will probably take some time to iron out details. Gas stations and toll booths will likely be the first to stop accepting cash.
rhinos welcome in GDL

4 white rhinos from France and Germany find a home in Guadalajara

0
The three females and one male bring genetic diversity to Mexico's rhino population, but flying several tonnes of horned beasts on a cargo plane for 12 hours was no easy task.
Beach scene in Puerto Vallarta.

MND Local Puerto Vallarta: Hurricanes keep coming, golf course disruption, free drinking water fountains

0
From illegal construction and controversial golf course tree culling to new drinking fountains and yet more hurricane impacts, life in Puerto Vallarta has not been dull lately, writes Debbie Slobe.
BETA Version - Powered by Perplexity