Court rules law enforcement authorities need court order to obtain bank records

The Supreme Court (SCJN) has ruled that it is unconstitutional for federal law enforcement authorities to request the bank records of accused criminals without a court order.

With six magistrates voting in favor and five against, the court determined that article 142 of the Credit Institutions Law – which allows the federal Attorney General’s Office (FGR) to obtain the financial records of suspected criminals – violates people’s constitutional right to privacy.

The ruling leaves thousands of cases pursued by the FGR, including those against former Pemex CEO Emilio Lozoya and ex-governors, hanging by a thread, the newspaper Milenio said.

The SCJN will sit again Monday to determine whether its decision will apply retroactively or only to future cases.

Some justices warned that depriving the FGR of its capacity to seek and obtain bank records will place money laundering, tax fraud and organized crime investigations at risk.

“The consequences that the establishment of this ruling might have concerns me,” said Jorge Mario Pardo Rebolledo.

Once the court’s ruling is formally pronounced, he said, financial evidence held by the FGR will “automatically” become “illegal – all the information, all the requests for bank information on which investigations are being processed.”

“. . . The Supreme Court must . . . be sensitive to the consequences of the judgements that it is establishing,” Pardo said.

Eduardo Medina Mora acknowledged that the right to privacy is of the utmost importance but argued that the right should be superseded when federal authorities are investigating crimes such as tax fraud, money laundering, terrorism or organized crime.

However, six judges including Chief Justice Arturo Zaldívar Lelo de Larrea didn’t share his view.

“There is something that is very important – at least for me – to take into account. The seriousness of the crime, the seriousness of the situation doesn’t excuse non-compliance with the constitution. The fight against crime must respect the constitution and human rights,” Zaldívar said.

“. . .I don’t think that being more relaxed with constitutional requirements is the right path for a constitutional court or for a democratic constitutional system. . .”

Source: Milenio (sp) 

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Cities across Mexico gathered in celebration of the 116th anniversary of the start of the Mexican Revolution on Friday.

Mexico’s week in review: Sheinbaum in China, Rodríguez at the mic and a kingpin behind bars

0
A quiet week with the president in China ended with the capture of "El Chapo Isidro" in Sinaloa. Also this week: Sheinbaum's meetings with Xi and Trump, another peso slide and the official return of measles.
The capture of Fausto Isidro Meza Flores, alias "El Chapo Isidro," was the result of coordination between Mexican and U.S. intelligence agencies.

Mexican special forces capture top FBI fugitive ‘El Chapo Isidro,’ unleashing a night of fire in Sinaloa

7
The arrest of the cartel kingpin is another high-profile blow against organized crime, following the fatal wounding of Jalisco New Generation Cartel (CJNG) leader Nemesio “El Mencho” Oseguera Cervantes in a military operation in Jalisco in February.
Mexico News Daily podcast "Trading Places" YouTube thumbnail

‘Trading Places’: A new podcast by Mexico News Daily

0
MND launches “Trading Places,” a new podcast where two hosts who each crossed the border in opposite directions talk with Mexican Americans about how they see both countries.
BETA Version - Powered by Perplexity