Friday, July 19, 2024

Interior minister defends pre-trial detention after human rights court ruling

Interior Minister Adán Augusto López has rejected a directive from the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR) on the use of preventive detention.

In a ruling made public in late January, the Costa Rica-based court said that Mexico violated the rights of personal freedom and presumption of innocence in a case involving three men who were arrested on the Mexico City-Veracruz highway in 2006 on organized crime charges and held in pre-trial prison for over 2 1/2 years before they were absolved.

Judges of the IACHR
Seven judges sit on the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IAHCR)

The IACHR consequently ordered the Mexican state to take a range of measures, among which was to “adapt” the country’s “internal legal system” with regard to the use of preventive detention. The court specifically ordered the elimination of a form of pre-trial detention known as arraigo.

Mexico’s Supreme Court (SCJN) ruled in November that current mandatory pre-trial detention arrangements – as set out in the constitution – were valid except in cases in which alleged perpetrators are accused of tax fraud, smuggling and tax evasion via the use of phony invoices.

During a visit to Tlaxcala last Friday, López charged that the IACHR demonstrated a lack of respect for Mexico in making its preventive detention order.

“It’s nonsense for the Inter-American Court to place itself above the constitution and it disrespects the Mexican state. There can be no power above the Mexican state, which among other things is the guarantor of social, political and economic stability in this country,” the interior minister said.

Ricardo Mejía at press conference
Ricardo Mejía Berdeja, former deputy for public security, explains the government’s position that eliminating mandatory pre-trial detention would lead to impunity at a September 2022 press conference. (Galo Cañas Rodríguez /

Before the SCJN ruling was handed down, the federal government argued in favor of maintaining prevailing mandatory pre-trial detention provisions, asserting that the measure is essential to ensure that suspects don’t evade justice and continue committing offenses.

López noted on Friday that the measure – which applies to people accused of serious crimes such as homicide, rape and kidnapping – “was declared constitutionally valid by the Supreme Court” with the exception of “crimes relating to tax fraud.”

No court can “force the Mexican state to modify the constitution,” the interior minister declared, adding that the 106-year-old document is “one of our sources of pride as Mexicans.”

Miguel Carbonell, a lawyer and director of his own legal studies center, took a different view on the regional court’s preventive prison directive, saying that the IACHR had set an “extremely important precedent that obliges us to modify this aberration provided for in the constitution since 2008.”

“For the first time in history, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has declared unconventional an article of the Mexican constitution. It will have to be modified as soon as possible and I hope that those who voted in favor of this reform in 2008 feel ashamed,” he wrote on Twitter.

With reports from Animal Político and Aristegui Noticias 

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Passengers wait in the crowded Cancún airport during the global Microsoft IT meltdown in Mexico.

Airport chaos and border bedlam: How the Microsoft IT meltdown is affecting Mexico

The IT outage that swamped Microsoft Windows computers around the world hit just as hard in Mexico, frustrating travelers of all stripes.
A man in a rain jacket points down at a channelized river below a bridge, full after recent rains.

Drought relents and reservoirs start to recover across rainy Mexico

As of July 15, the area of the country suffering from drought was down to almost 50%.
AMLOAMLO and Donald Trump walk down a red carpet in an elegant hallway. and Donald Trump walk down a red carpet in a long corridor.

In response to Trump speech, AMLO plans to send his ‘friend Donald’ a letter

"I think they're not informing him well about the migration issue and also about the importance of maintaining economic integration between the United States, Mexico and Canada," AMLO said Friday morning.