Thursday, May 23, 2024

US senators urge action on “surge” of Mexican steel imports

United States senators urged the Biden administration on Tuesday to take action on a “surge” of Mexican steel imports. 

The bipartisan group of 14 U.S. senators who signed the letter, addressed to U.S. Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo and Trade Representative Katherine Tai, are demanding action against an “unsustainable” rise in imports of steel from Mexico. 

USTR Katherine Tai
The request by the senators went to U.S. Trade Representative Katherine Tai. (Photo: U.S. government)

The politicians stressed the possibility of requesting a consultation under the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) if the “Mexican government refuses to repair this breach.”

The letter references section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act, which permits the Executive to impose tariffs in the event that imports “threaten national security.” Section 232 is controversial: the World Trade Organization ruled in December that the tariffs it imposes violate global trade rules. The Biden Administration stated in response that it would continue to impose the tariffs, referring to it as an issue of “national security.”  

Section 232 was invoked by former U.S. president Donald Trump in 2018 when he imposed tariffs of 25% on Mexican steel as part of his “America First” economic policy, resulting in several countries’ governments filing legal actions against the U.S. with the WTO, including Mexico.

Trump removed the tariff on Mexico in 2019 during North American trade negotiations, and Mexico withdrew its action with the WTO. As part of the agreement, the U.S. and Mexico agreed to continually monitor the trade balance of steel and aluminum between their two countries.

Under the agreement, if imports of those products surge “meaningfully beyond historic volumes of trade over a period of time,” the importing country can request a consultation with the exporting country.

“After such consultation, the importing country may impose tariffs of 25% for steel and 10% for aluminum,” the agreement said.      

Both countries also agreed to implement measures to prevent the importation of aluminum and steel that is unfairly subsidized or sold at “dumped” prices.

The senators argue that Mexico’s steel imports have violated the 2019 agreement.

U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren
The bipartisan group of U.S. senators that penned the letter requesting action includes Republicans Tom Cotton, Mark Rubio, and Rick Scott as well as Democrats Tammy Baldwin, Bob Casey, Jr. and Elizabeth Warren, seen here. (Photo 155755433 © Jhansen2 |

“Since the U.S. lifted section 232 tariffs, Mexican steel conduit imports have reached unprecedented levels and Mexico’s penetration of the U.S. steel conduit market has more than tripled while demand from U.S. consumers has fallen,” the senators’ letter said. 

“The wave of Mexican steel imports has already contributed to the loss of over 200 steel jobs in California and led to the closing of one of less than a dozen American factories that produce steel conduit.” 

The senators allege that steel imports from Mexico have increased 73% in the last three years compared to the “pre-section 232 2015–2017 baseline.” 

Semi-finished steel and long product imports increased by 120%, and steel conduits increased by 577%. 

The Mexican Chamber of the Iron and Steel Industry (Canacero) rejected what it referred to as “protectionist claims,” noting that the United States exports more steel to Mexico than it imports. 

“It is twice the share of Mexican exports to [the U.S.],” Cancaero said in a statement on Sunday, noting that the market share of Mexican steel imports to the U.S. represents only 3.3% of domestic consumption while steel from the United States makes up 14.6% of Mexico’s consumption. 

Mexico-U.S. trade delegation meeting in Washington DC in December 2022
A team of U.S. and Mexican trade and economy officials meet in Washington D.C. in December, led by Tai, center left, and Mexico’s Economy Minister Raquel Buenrostro, center right. (Katherine Tai/Twitter)

“We must work to balance the market and strengthen our value chains instead of wanting to continue building walls… the real challenge for the American industry is on the other side of the Pacific, not south of the Rio Grande.” 

Canacero and the Mexican authorities will carry out an objective analysis of the situation to better understand the benefits generated by regional trade. 

With reports from Reforma and El Economista

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Man in Mexico City drinking a plastic cup of water at a hydration station during a heat wave.

Mexico is about to see its highest temperatures ever, experts warn

Mexico is about to experience record high temperatures as the third of a projected five heat waves scorches the country.
Scene of the accident at a baseball stadium in Monterrey

Stage collapse at Nuevo León campaign event kills at least 9, injures dozens

Presidential candidate Jorge Álvarez Máynez was on the stage at the Citizens Movement (MC) rally when the accident occurred, but he was not injured.
Clandestine lab in Sonora

US Secretary of State Blinken says Mexico has seized a ‘record amount of fentanyl’

In an appearance before a U.S. congressional committee, Blinken said the two countries need to continue and step up collaborative efforts against fentanyl.