Wednesday, October 9, 2024

Judicial reform takes effect after AMLO signs it into law

President Andrés Manuel López Obrador on Sunday promulgated the federal government’s judicial reform, setting the stage for thousands of judges, including all Supreme Court justices, to be elected by Mexican citizens starting next year.

A decree signed by López Obrador in which various articles of the Mexican Constitution were declared to be “reformed, added to” or “repealed” was published in the government’s official gazette, four days after the Senate approved the judicial reform bill and three days after a majority of state legislatures ratified it. The reform takes effect Monday.

A group of Mexico City legislators standing by the head of the legislature's bench and behind it, holding signs that say "The Reform goes forward!"
Mexico City lawmakers celebrating their legislature’s ratification of President López Obrador’s judicial reform bill after it passed in the federal Congress. (Andrea Murcia Monsivaís/Cuartoscuro)

In a video posted to social media, the president, seated alongside President-elect Claudia Sheinbaum, said he was signing the reform into law “with the intent of improving the judicial power because we need justice to get to everyone.”

Among the other aims of the reform, he said, are to eliminate corruption in the judiciary and for judges, magistrates and Supreme Court justices to apply the law equally to all.

“We should have an authentic, a true rule of law, not a crooked one,” said López Obrador, who asserts that many judges are corrupt and has been angered by court decisions handed down against his government’s projects and policies.

“The simulation must end because it was said we lived in a democracy but we didn’t. An oligarchy dominated. Those right at the top were the ones who were in charge, a minority with the facade of democracy,” he said.

AMLO and Claudia Sheinbaum wave at a civic event
Claudia Sheinbaum has expressed full support for President López Obrador’s constitutional reforms. (Cuartoscuro)

“There was simulation. Now it’s different, now it’s the people who rule, the people who decide,” López Obrador said.

He described Sunday — the eve of Mexico’s Independence Day — as an “historic day,” considering the publication of the judicial reform decree in the government’s gazette.

Sheinbaum, the president’s “witness of honor,” applauded the president after he uttered three words — “voy a firmar,” or “I’m going to sign” the decree.

She will be sworn in as Mexico’s first female president on Oct. 1, and will immediately have immense power as a coalition led by the ruling Morena party has a supermajority in the lower house of Congress and a near-supermajority in the Senate.

Mexico Supreme Court justices
Under the reform, all federal judges including the Supreme Court justices (seen here) will be elected from a pre-selected pool of candidates. (SCJN)

Many other constitutional reforms that López Obrador sent to Congress in February, and which Sheinbaum fully supports, could be approved in the coming months.

The president promulgated the judicial reform despite a court in Colima ruling against its publication in the government’s gazette.

Morena Senator Ernestina Godoy, who will serve as legal counsel to Sheinbaum, asserted Friday that the court order was not valid given that two-thirds of lawmakers in both houses of Congress had approved the judicial reform.

“One power can’t do that to another power,” she said.

The most controversial aspect of the judicial reform is the provision to allow citizens to directly elect all members of the judiciary, including Supreme Court justices and other federal judges.

In accordance with the reform, thousands of judges — approximately half of the nation’s judiciary — will be elected in “extraordinary elections” on June 1, 2025. Another round of elections will be held in 2027 at the same time midterm congressional elections take place.

Protesters against the judicial reform in Zacatecas
The judicial reform bill has generated controversy and protests around the country for weeks. (Cuartoscuro)

The National Electoral Institute will be responsible for organizing the judicial elections.

Critics of the judicial reform argue that judges sympathetic to Morena will come to dominate the judiciary as the president and the Congress will nominate candidates.

There are also concerns that the reform will have a negative impact on foreign investment and Mexico’s trade relations, including those with its key regional partners, the United States and Canada.

López Obrador and Sheinbaum have dismissed all criticism of the reform, portraying concerns about it as unfounded.

What else does the judicial reform change?

Among the other changes in the judicial reform are:

  • The reduction of the number of Supreme Court justices to 9 from 11.
  • The reduction of justices’ terms to 12 years from 15.
  • The reduction of the experience required to serve as a justice and judge.
  • The adjustment of salaries so that no judge earns more than the president.
  • The elimination of the Federal Judiciary Council.
  • The creation of a Tribunal of Judicial Discipline that could sanction and fire judges found to have acted improperly or illegally.
  • The use of “faceless,” or unidentified judges, to preside over organized crime cases.
  • An expansion of the crimes for which pre-trial detention can be enforced.

With reports from El Financiero, Reforma, La Jornada and Aristegui Noticias

6 COMMENTS

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Security Minister Omar García Harfuch stressed that national security is a "shared responsibility" among all federal entities.

García Harfuch presents 4 pillars of national security strategy

11
Steering youth away from crime by increasing access to a better quality of life is central to the Sheinbaum administration's security strategy.
Sheinbaum stands in front of a tri-colored banner, as military officials salute at her side.

Hugs or bullets? Sheinbaum begins to define her security strategy

4
The administration has allowed some media outlets a preview of how it plans to rein in violence over Sheinbaum's first 100 days in office.
Mexico City Mayor Clara Brugada salutes the flag as she is sworn in as mayor

Clara Brugada sworn in as mayor of Mexico City

0
In her inauguration speech, Brugada promised billions of pesos to improve water access in the metropolis.