Friday, February 14, 2025

Mexican moviegoers are asking for a refund after watching ‘Emilia Pérez’ in theaters

Mexico’s Federal Consumer Protection Agency (Profeco) is investigating complaints from consumers seeking a refund from the Mexican movie theater chain Cinépolis after watching the film “Emilia Pérez.” 

Since last Thursday, the agency has received many complaints on social media from consumers demanding the money spent on their movie tickets back, the head of Profeco Iván Escalante said during President Claudia Sheinbaum’s Monday morning press conference

Several moviegoers criticized the cinema for allegedly not honoring its “‘Cinépolis Guarantee,” which promises to reimburse the cost of your ticket if you are dissatisfied with the film. 

“We contacted [Cinépolis] immediately,” said Escalante. “What they’re telling us is that it was a guarantee that they ran as a campaign to recommend certain films, but that in reality, since [the campaign] had been around for a long time and had not created any major problems, they left the guarantee in place, but had not trained their staff on how to [administer reimbursements].” 

Emilia Pérez, directed by French filmmaker Jacques Audiard, had 10 nominations and four wins at the Golden Globes on Jan. 5 in Los Angeles. It has since broken the record for the most Oscar nominations earned by a non-English language film, with 13.  

However, many Mexicans have responded negatively to the film, which portrays the leader of a cartel as a redeemed figure. They criticize the director for a perceived lack of cultural awareness about the disappearance of hundreds of thousands of people in Mexico as a result of cartel activity. 

Zoe Saldana and Sofia Gascon Alarcon in a scene from Emilia Perez
Despite sweeping the Golden Globes, “Emilia Pérez” has deeply offended a large segment of Mexico’s population. (Netflix) 

Turning the country’s biggest security crisis into a musical where the protagonist is one of the perpetrators of that crisis shows a profound lack of respect,” wrote Mexican writer María Meléndez for Mexico News Daily.

“The impunity enjoyed by those responsible for over 300,000 dead and 121,000 missing isn’t material for a comedy,” added Meléndez.

At its Mexican premiere on Jan. 15, the French filmmaker responded to the criticism. “The drama of the missing is something that shocks me deeply,” Audiard said. “It’s a tragedy that’s largely invisible outside of Mexico, and my goal was to generate dialogue, not offense.”

Profeco said that it is currently reviewing demands for refunds from consumers who paid to watch “Emilia Perez” at Cinépolis theaters.  

The agency has recommended that Cinépolis “recommend” rather than “guarantee” films under its policy, to avoid customer disappointment. 

With reports from El Universal, Aristegui Noticias, The Guardian and El País

9 COMMENTS

  1. Oh, man. I’d been excited to see this and finally did this past weekend… forget culturally insensitive; it was a spectacularly bad film, missing every mark it meant to hit. I am baffled about all of the Oscar nominations it received. The music was weird and monotone, and sometimes it wasn’t even clear if characters were delivering actual lines or “rapping.”

  2. Please don’t tell me that Mexico is going woke too! The u.s. movies and “popular” culture in general has been putting woke bombs for years, but they really ramped it up when Biden took office. The wokies have been condemned and exposed as leftist idiots so they’re failing miserably in the u.s. Please Mexico… don’t go down that road. Speak out loudly against the woke idiots. Gracias..

  3. Was it “bad” because people didn’t like the message – a redeemed cartel leader as protagonist who happened to be trans? Was it “good” because it featured a sympathetic, redeemed, trans cartel leader? Same political coin, different sides. Was the Netflix series El Chapo any good because it was a violent crime drama, not a musical, even though it presented Guzman in a sympathetic light from time to time? I liked both for different reasons. I generally can’t stand musicals but I enjoyed Emilia Perez. Fighting the cartels and impunity in general is a separate issue entirely.

  4. I watched the film. It was good, not great, but good. It was inventive and the music was fresh and raw, I can see why critics loved it, it very very original and novel.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Band playing onstage at the International Cervantino Festival in 2024. The band of all men and one woman are dressed in traditional Mexican shirts, black pants and white campesino hats. One of the man is holding his hat up and out at the audience.

Veracruz and United Kingdom to be Festival Cervantino 2025 guests of honor

0
This festival, held annually in Guanajuato city, will take place this year from Oct. 10 to Oct. 26, featuring artists and performers from around the world.
Ynés Mexía

The strange story of Mexico’s most brilliant botanist

3
If Indiana Jones went after rare plants instead of rare treasures, he'd still not come close to the adventures of Ynés Mexía.
Oaxaca artisans protest cultural appropriation

Oaxaca artisans accuse U.S. brands of stealing traditional designs

7
The Culture Ministry promised to initiate immediate legal proceedings against the brands accused of plagiarizing Mixtec intellectual property.