Court halts work on Royal Caribbean’s mega-project in Mahahual, QR

A court in Quintana Roo state ordered a provisional suspension of works by Royal Caribbean on its “Perfect Day” tourism project in Mahahual on Monday, while the potential environmental implications of the project are being assessed. 

The injunction was requested by the civil society organization Defending the Right to a Healthy Environment (DMAS). The group argues that there are irregularities in the authorization of land-use changes provided to the Royal Caribbean cruise line.

DMAS stressed that it is not against the proposed water park but that “we are in favor of respecting the law, urban planning, and the community’s right to a healthy environment.”

Royal Caribbean first presented “Perfect Day” to a group of journalists in October, during which the U.S. firm’s director of innovation, Jay Schneider, said the project is expected to attract up to 6 million tourists a year and transform the fishing village of Mahahual into a stronghold for the American cruise line.

The proposed 80-hectare water park is set to be developed across from the Mahahual cruise ship pier in southern Quintana Roo. The initial plan outlines an operational capacity of up to 21,000 cruise ship tourists per day, as well as 2,500 employees for the park’s operation.

Activists have long raised concerns about the project, saying that the park will worsen infrastructure woes in the 2,600-person town, which is already battling wastewater problems.

On Monday, a federal judge called for a halt to operations on environmental grounds, as the project could damage mangroves, put pressure on water rights and harm existing infrastructure due to its scale.

Developers will not be permitted to work on the project while the injunction is being resolved.

A hearing to assess the possibility of a definitive suspension is expected to be held in the coming days.

When questioned about the potential impact of the project on the mangroves, Schneider said, “We are not going to touch anything in the mangrove conservation area.” 

He went on to suggest that the mangroves are already being damaged by pollution associated with the municipal wastewater treatment plant and that Royal Caribbean aimed to restore the mangroves, as well as construct a new wastewater treatment plant for the community.

With reports from La Jornada and El Financiero

3 COMMENTS

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Mexico's navy has deployed 11 coastal sargassum collection vessels, each with a collection capacity of 20 tonnes; one offshore sargassum collection vessel; two amphibious sargassum collection vessels; 18 smaller boats; and 13,230 meters of containment barriers in Isla Mujeres, Benito Juárez, Puerto Morelos, Playa del Carmen, Cozumel, Tulum and Othón P. Blanco.

Playa del Carmen starts October with new sargassum arrivals, though seasonal decline is underway

0
The threat of sargassum remains active along Quintana Roo's coastline, but a progressive reduction is expected heading into November and December. 
Sketch from Bel Woodhouse

From jungle to wildflowers: How Mexico made me a botanical artist

2
Mexico's natural wonders, from jungles to wildflowers and their pollinators, inspired Bel Woodhouse to pick up a sketchbook again after a long hiatus ... with remarkable results.
Students from the Emiliano Zapata Popular Revolutionary Union took to the streets of Toluca in México state to commemorate the students killed on Oct. 2, 1968, in Tlatelolco and the 43 missing students from Ayotzinapa.

Mexico’s week in review: Peso sinks to 18 as school safety, storms and trade talks dominate

1
Attacks on and by students collided with the anniversaries of past violence this week, while the peso behaved as erratically as the weather. Here's what happened the week of Sept. 28 in Mexico.
BETA Version - Powered by Perplexity