Saturday, July 13, 2024

Jalisco’s bumper crop of berry farms may hurt locals more than help

Berries are in. Everyone likes them because they are rich in antioxidants and because people in the know are interested in healthy food.

Mexico has certainly cashed in on this berry-loving revolution. More than 75% of fresh blackberries consumed in the United States are grown in Mexico, according to the North American Raspberry and Blackberry Association. The Berry Rush is in full swing in the states of Michoacán, Jalisco, Baja California, Guanajuato, México state and Puebla.

Farmers are ready to try something new instead of corn and potatoes. Berry-producing companies have figured out how to consistently produce great harvests here — and they guarantee Mexican farmers that they will buy their produce. What could be better?

According to the newspaper El Informador, berry cultivation in Jalisco has tripled in the last five years and now outstrips exports of the state’s emblematic beverage, tequila. Berry-growing companies arrive in farming communities with big promises of prosperity: money for landowners who lease out their property to the company and good-paying jobs for local workers.

Berries Paradise, for example, founded in 2008 in Tuxpan, Jalisco, describes itself as “an environmentally friendly operation,” that “allows people to prosper in Mexico without the need to migrate to survive.” Berrymex — founded in Jocotepec, Jalisco, in 1991 — says its focus is on “delighting consumers while generating prosperity for our workers in the field and in the communities where we operate.”

Berries grown in Mexico
Berries are healthy and growing them in Mexico is profitable, but a price is being paid. Government of Mexico

At first glance, it would appear that the only negative aspect of berry growing is its need to be done in what growers call multi-bay tunnels, typically made of white plastic sheeting that’s visible for kilometers. Fields planted with corn, potatoes or cabbages are green and fit right in with the trees and bushes you expect to see in the countryside.

But plastic is anything but charming, which is why Pueblos Mágicos like Tapalpa, Jalisco, are up in arms about them, saying that the berry farms’ visuals affect their picturesque image. “State and federal authorities have abandoned our communities when it comes to controlling berry farming here,” said Antonio Morales, Tapalpa’s ex-mayor.

Other communities claim the berry industry has brought them nothing but calamities.

Quila el Grande, Jalisco, which sits at the northern end of La Sierra de Quila —  an extraordinarily beautiful protected area famous for its pine and oak forests, huge rocks and waterfalls, lies 80 kilometers southwest of Guadalajara. It’s one of these towns with green hills that have turned white.

“A berry company called Vitatellus got a foot in the door here by buying a ranch,” said local businessman Sergio Camacho. “Then, once they were established, they began renting the surrounding land. They began with 40 or 50 hectares, but now they’ve got more than 100.”

“The main problem with Vitatellus, which seems to work hand-in-hand with Berries Paradise,” says Camacho, “is that they’re causing us to run out of water. They need so much that they are continually digging deeper wells in order to get it.”

road ruined by berry growing companies in Quila, Jalisco
One of many roads ruined by berry companies near Quila. Cindy Valenzisi

Not only that, but according to Camacho, although berry companies purport to bring prosperity to small communities, what they actually do is bring in cheap labor from faraway places.

“Let’s say, for every 100 people working for Vitatellus, four are from Quila and all the others are from Hidalgo, Chiapas, Toluca and who knows where else,” he said.

But even those imported workers aren’t profiting, Camacho said.

“They tell people in Chiapas that they are going to make big money, but once they’re here, they pay them una miseria (a pittance), and now what can they do?” he explained. “They’re not the least bit happy, but they’re stuck. These people are being abused.”

The problems also expand out to local farmers, who don’t usually have 1.7 million pesos handy to invest in berry farming and lease out their land to a large berry-growing company for about what they would get if they planted more traditional crops.

“What they don’t know,” says Francisco Quintero of the Selva Negra Foundation, “is that they will never be able to grow corn on their land in the future because the berry companies sterilize it with boron gas — which, because it is bio-accumulative, stays put in the soil permanently.”

Berry farms on mountain in Quila el Grande
That’s not snow in those Jalisco mountains, that’s a carpet of plastic from berry farms in Quila el Grande. Cindy Valenzisi

Berry farms also often lead to the degradation of local roads due to their use of heavy machinery, as well as the refusal of many of these companies to cooperate in road maintenance and repair.

“And then there is the sewage problem,” Camacho said. “The huge number of workers brought here from outside are overloading the sewage system. All the aguas negras (human waste) produced by this expanded population are running directly into the river, causing a disastrous pollution problem. And because they’re drying up our aquifers, there’s very little water in the river anymore, just sewage.”

Camacho’s uncle, Ignacio Luquín, agrees with his nephew’s claims.

“But,” he says, “I want to add something to his comments. The laborers [that] they are busing in from all over Mexico are being given food and shelter all right, but they have to pay for it. The food is bad, the dormitories are a disgrace and they’ve set up ‘company stores’ reminiscent of the tiendas de raya in vogue during the last days before the Mexican Revolution.”

The tiendas de raya played a strategic role in entrapping laborers in the days of Mexican president Porfirio Díaz. Miners, for example, could get anything they wanted on credit at the company store, including tempting items they really didn’t need. Soon they racked up huge debts they could never pay off, assuring the mining companies of a never-ending supply of cheap labor.

All the berry companies mentioned here were contacted for comment, but none responded.

Waterfall in Sierra de Quila Park, Jalisco
One of 11 waterfalls in Sierra de Quila Park. Wells dug by berry companies are drying up the aquifers.

“This was such a beautiful place to live,” Quila resident Cindy Valenzisi wrote to the newspaper The Guadalajara Reporter, “but, unfortunately, it is being used and abused by a berry company that continues to expand. How can we stop, slow or change the impending doom looming over Quila?”

Berry Farm Driveby Quila Jalisco Mexico
A look at how Quila’s picturesque landscape has been transformed by berry farming.


The writer has lived near Guadalajara, Jalisco, since 1985. His most recent book is Outdoors in Western Mexico, Volume Three. More of his writing can be found on his blog.


Mexican berry street vendor
Berries are appearing everywhere in Mexico, even on street corners.


berry farms aerial view in San Isidro Mazatepec, Jalisco
A bird’s-eye view of berry farms covering the landscape of rural San Isidro Mazatepec, Jalisco.


Berry farm workers in Jalisco
Despite promises of bringing local jobs, berry farms often bring in laborers from other states. They then end up trapped in jobs they can’t afford to leave. Lucía Vergara and Adolfo Valtierra


Quila el Grande, Jalisco
How Quila looked before the berry farms came.
Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Satellite image of North America

Canada vs. Mexico in Numbers

While characteristics like land area differentiate the North American neighbors, Mexico and Canada also share some surprising similarities.
A rocket blasts through clouds and into the blue sky, representing Querétaro airport's goal of becoming an aerospace port

Querétaro airport on track to become Mexico’s first aerospace port

Preliminary studies show the airport's location, climate and runway are appropriate for spacecraft takeoff and landing base.
Visitors take photos near a statue of Poseidon in the ocean outside Progreso, Yucatán

Authorities ‘close’ controversial Poseidon statue in Yucatán

The Greek deity recently achieved viral fame after social media users called it an affront to the Maya god Chaac. Now, it's indefinitely closed.