Saturday, May 17, 2025

Incompetent bureaucrats, naivete and doomed policies spell a dim future

0
Pemex chief Romero, an agronomist, speaks at the president's morning press conference.
Pemex chief Romero, an agronomist, speaks at the president's morning press conference.

In the first of this two-part series I wrote about President Andrés Manuel López Obrador’s (AMLO’s) efforts since he took office last December to consolidate power and undermine the country’s democratic institutions.

In this second installment, I detail the scale of incompetence evident in his administration as well as his doomed security and economic policies.

AMLO has said that the ills of Mexico stem from a “neoliberal” economic model, which he asserts has ruled the country since 1983. As such, one of his first priorities was to get rid of the “patrician” technocrats by firing them directly, in most cases breaking prevailing labor laws.

He has also decreed that no one in the public sector can earn more than the president, including employees of the federal government, as well as members of Congress, the judiciary, state-owned enterprises and autonomous state entities. At the same time he lowered his own salary to US$5,596 per month (at the prevailing exchange rate at the time of writing).

As was to be predicted, that edict meant that thousands of well-paid and highly competent technocrats, most of them with degrees from the best universities of the world, left the public sector and many also left the country.

On top of the devastating loss of human capital, the new government has placed patently incompetent – but loyal – apparatchiks in virtually all high-ranking jobs in the public sector.

One example suffices to illustrate this disaster: the chairmanship of Pemex, Mexico’s oil conglomerate and the country’s largest corporation, was entrusted to AMLO’s old pal Octavio Romero, an agronomist from a fourth-tier provincial university in Tabasco, the home state of AMLO.

The list of inept or sinister characters that populate this administration is unprecedented and it has already had dire consequences for the country and its economy. Those that are somewhat competent – though not when compared to previous administrations – are overwhelmed or, worse, charged with impossible tasks for which they do not have the personnel, talent or resources to achieve. A few examples illustrate this situation.

All the purchases of the public sector have been centralized in the Secretary of Finance’s office of administration, which represents a huge bottleneck for a well-functioning economy. Some of the results have been devastating:

• The country had severe gasoline shortages at the pump level in January and February because the order to import the necessary amounts was rescinded by someone who didn’t understand the consequences. AMLO used the real problem of illegal extractions from pipelines as a cover, but it had nothing to do with the lack of fuel.

• For more than a month earlier this year the splinter union of teachers – not its main union, the SNTE, but a highly radicalized faction of rebellious teachers with a stronghold in the poorest states – decided to block the passage of railroads near several crucial seaports, causing billions of dollars in losses to business. After failing to limit the damage, the government caved in to demands that have dashed the hope of much-needed education reform.

• Only two weeks ago, Mexico City, which has a long record of severe pollution due to its geography, was choked with the worst air in its history as the result of the dry season and an unusual proliferation of forest fires. It turned out that the Secretariat of Finance had cut the budget to entities in charge of firefighting and the special program to hire extra workers just when the fire season was arriving. Hasty and misguided cost-saving such as this has been used to fund AMLO’s populist hand-outs and pet infrastructure projects.

• Just last week the CEO of the Social Security Institute – the IMSS is an institution that doubles as medical-care provider and pension fund – resigned with a nine-page letter where he describes in detail how the IMSS budget was mercilessly axed, making an already mediocre service provider much worse. Other health sector entities have suffered a similar fate and the country is now facing a crisis of scarcity of medical attention and supplies.

In his eagerness to change everything, AMLO decided to destroy 18 years of experience in developing a national police force capable of restoring security to the nation and invented, instead, a national guard that is nominally a civilian force but will be run by the military.

The force is organized like the army and most of its members will come from the military. The operational logic of this new force is designed to be territorial and not functional, very much like how military bases are deployed throughout the country. There is no mention of units performing key jobs of intelligence, investigation and forensic science, as in the now-defunct Federal Police.

There are no incentives for the state and local police forces to improve, and some experts believe that this will lead to a substitution of the local forces by the National Guard, entailing more centralization. The civilian command of the guard is in the hands of one politician with no relevant experience to speak of.

One of AMLO’s guiding principles is not to fight transnational criminal organizations since he attributes their rising power to the precarious economic conditions that resulted in poverty in many parts of the country. He expects, in return for a de facto truce with drug cartels, a decrease in violence.

So far, he has fulfilled his part of the deal, while organized crime has increased its activities rendering the first semester of AMLO’s tenure as the bloodiest in the country’s history.

Regarding corruption, AMLO’s attitude is equally naive. Since he declares himself to be personally honest, that means that everyone around him must be the same. Meanwhile, 85% of the contracts of the public sector and its enterprises have been granted to suppliers without competitive bidding, far more than any previous administration.

With this careless procurement process, much lower salaries for the bureaucracy and no transparency or oversight mechanisms, corruption is sure to flourish as never before.

All the indicators are that the economy is screeching to a halt as there is no private investment and government spending is down substantially. The key economic problem is uncertainty, mainly from two sources: lack of confidence in the new administration and its economic strategy, and doubts about the viability that the revised North American Free Trade Agreement will be ratified by the U.S. Congress.

So far, public finances have remained under control, but only due to the savage cutting of spending by slashing salaries, firing people and radically cutting crucial government functions, as illustrated above. But this will not be sufficient to support the spending whims of AMLO and his absurd projects, all of which will demand an increase in resources that will have to come from deficit financing.

While the value of the Mexican peso has remained relatively stable in recent months due to extremely tight monetary policy, that will all change when rating agencies downgrade Mexico and strip it of its investment grade rating. When this happens in the second half of this year, as I expect, the exchange rate will sink as portfolio investment flees the country in massive capital flight.

Opinion polls that gave AMLO an astonishing approval rating of 80% after his first 100 days in office have finally started to fall. As more people suffer the direct consequences of this government’s ineptitude, popular support will surely plummet.

Manuel Suárez-Mier is an economist and former Mexican government and central bank official. He has taught at universities in Mexico and the US for 40 years.

El Chapo’s mother hopes to hug her son on prison visit

0
Loera speaks to reporters in Mexico City on Friday.
Loera speaks to reporters in Mexico City on Friday.

The mother of convicted ex-drug lord Joaquín “El Chapo” Guzmán has been granted a humanitarian visa by the United States so she can visit her son in prison.

María Consuelo Loera Pérez, 91, addressed journalists from a wheelchair in front of the United States Embassy in Mexico City Friday, affirming in a feeble voice that she longed to be reunited with her son.

“I hope they will allow me to give him a hug . . . and I wish they would free him.”

Loera was accompanied by two of her daughters — El Chapo’s sisters — who were also granted visas to visit the former head of the Sinaloa Cartel.

Guzmán was found guilty by a jury in a United States federal court on February 12 on charges of trafficking heroin, cocaine, marijuana and methamphetamines into the U.S. He faces the possibility of getting life in prison in a maximum-security penitentiary at his June 25 sentencing.

The former drug boss’s lawyers called the trial, which heard stories of bloody murders, bribes made to politicians, cocaine hidden in jalapeño jars and jewel-encrusted guns, a farce. While the defense did not deny El Chapo’s crimes, they alleged that the prosecution’s cases rested on witness evidence delivered by other criminal suspects who hoped to receive lighter prison sentences.

The lawyers also claimed that the result of the trial had been affected by the extensive media coverage of the case and asserted that they intended to appeal the verdict.

Guzmáns mother said she and her daughters had not yet set a date for their visit. She thanked both President López Obrador and the United States Embassy for their roles in making the trip possible.

Loera first approached the president for help in February, passing him a letter when he visited El Chapo’s home town of Badiraguato, Sinaloa. In the letter, she said she had not seen her son in over five years and that “with my advanced age and not being able to see him, only my faith in Jesus Christ is keeping me alive.”

López Obrador told reporters that he intervened out of sympathy for the woman.

Loera said if she is allowed to give her son anything during her visit, she will take him his favorite dish of homemade enchiladas.

Source: Milenio (sp), USA Today (en)

Tabasco refinery project initiated despite missing studies and permits

0
Dozens of people began lining up Sunday night to apply for jobs at the refinery site. Hiring began today.
Dozens of people began lining up Sunday night to apply for jobs at the refinery site. Hiring began today.

President López Obrador officially launched construction of the new US $8-billion refinery in Tabasco yesterday even though some studies for the project haven’t been carried out and it lacks all the required permits.

The president reiterated his pledge that the Dos Bocas refinery will be completed in three years and not cost more than 150 billion pesos.

Mexico “depends too much on buying foreign gasoline,” López Obrador said, promising that while the refinery is being built energy costs won’t increase and that when it has been completed – and the country’s six existing refineries have been rehabilitated – they will come down.

López Obrador announced last month that the state oil company will build the refinery on the Gulf of Mexico coast because the bids made by private companies were too high and their estimated time frames to complete the project were too long.

Last week, he said that his administration has “prior authorization” to begin work.

However, the Mexican Center for Environmental Law and Greenpeace warned that construction of the project could not yet legally start because its approval was based on a 2012 environmental impact statement (EIS) for an oil field, not a refinery, and it lacked other required permits as stipulated by environmental laws.

Despite their opposition, Energy Secretary Rocio Nahle said yesterday that the EIS approved by the Security, Energy and Environmental Agency (ASEA) authorizes the commencement of conditioning work at the site.

“Pemex, IMP [the Mexican Institute of Petroleum] and the Secretariat of Energy have worked constantly with ASEA and Semarnat [the Secretariat of the Environment] to comply with . . . the technical study for the change of land use, it’s already pre-approved and this week the final ruling will be presented,” she said.

Nahle added that an environmental risk assessment and a regional environmental impact statement will be presented to the relevant authorities within a period of 17 days.

At the end of June, she said, “we will be tendering six construction contracts . . . so that all the parts that are under construction can start at the same time and we can finish the refinery in three years.”

Construction of the refinery will generate more than 100,000 direct and indirect jobs, according to the government, and once in operation will have the capacity to produce 340,000 barrels of petroleum a day.

However, experts have questioned the heavily-indebted state oil company’s technical capacity to execute the project while the Mexican Institute for Competitiveness, a think tank, warned that the refinery only has a 2% chance of success.

Source: Reforma (sp) 

Homes, vehicles damaged after Jalisco river overflows its banks

0
A street San Gabriel yesterday.
A street in San Gabriel yesterday.

The San Gabriel river in Jalisco overflowed its banks yesterday, carrying a deluge of mud, timber and debris into the small town of the same name.

Floodwaters damaged dwellings and vehicles, affecting dozens of families. A 36-year-old woman has been confirmed dead and at least 10 others have been reported missing.

A preparatory school run by the University of Guadalajara was set up as a shelter for those affected by the flooding.

Flood damage in San Gabriel.
Flood damage in San Gabriel.

The National Water Commission has forecast intense isolated torrential storms and the risk of mudslides in Guerrero, Veracruz and Oaxaca.

Very strong and isolated storms, also with mudslide risk, were forecast for Tamaulipas, San Luis Potosí, Querétaro, Hidalgo, Puebla and Chiapas.

Source: El Occidental (sp), El Informador (sp)

UPDATE, June 3, 5:05 CDT: Authorities say two people have been confirmed dead and five are missing. Residents have claimed that the river overflowed not due to a rainstorm as previously thought but because of a landslide caused by deforestation. There had been no rain yesterday.

Desborda río en San Gabriel; afecta a miles

Tariffs won’t slow Central American migration: foreign secretary

0
Ebrard, center, listens as Economy Secretary Graciela Márquez addresses the press conference.
Ebrard, center, listens as Economy Secretary Graciela Márquez addresses the press conference.

Slapping tariffs on Mexican exports to the United States will not slow down Central American migration flows, Foreign Secretary Marcelo Ebrard said today.

Ebrard told a press conference at the Mexican embassy in Washington that “the imposition of tariffs together with the [United States’] decision to cancel aid programs in northern Central American countries could have a counter-productive effect and not reduce migration flows.”

He explained that “the tariffs could cause financial and economic instability,” which would reduce Mexico’s “capacity to deal with migration and offer alternatives to new migrants,” most of whom come from the Northern Triangle countries of Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala.

President Donald Trump announced Thursday that he was placing a 5% tariff on all goods from Mexico to pressure the country to stop the movement of undocumented migrants across its northern border.

President López Obrador promptly dispatched a Mexican delegation led by Ebrard to the United States capital, where meetings with United States officials aimed at reaching a deal to stop the tariffs are taking place this week.

The foreign secretary told reporters that Mexico is already implementing measures to stop migrants reaching the border, pointing out that the government has offered many the opportunity to apply for refugee status.

In the first five months of the year, 24,451 people applied for asylum in Mexico, Ebrard said, adding that “if current trends continue, the number could reach more than 60,000 at the end of 2019.”

He also said that more than 80,000 migrants and 400 persons involved in people smuggling have been arrested in Mexico since the new government took office in December.

“Without these efforts . . . an additional quarter million migrants would arrive at the United States border in 2019,” Ebrard said.

The secretary added that Mexico wants to work with the United States to address the root causes of migration from Central American countries – namely poverty and violence.

Late last month, Mexico proposed that the United States fund seven development projects aimed at generating economic opportunities and well-being in Central America and stemming the northward flow of migrants.

“Mexico has the belief that . . . attending to the causes of migration will provide an answer to this problem,” Ebrard said.

“[We will] continue working with the United States to deal with issues of common interest. We want our governments to remain friends and partners.”

Ebrard is expected to meet with Secretary of State Mike Pompeo this week to try to dissuade the imposition of the new tariffs, and President López Obrador said Saturday that he expected “good results” from the bilateral talks.

However, Trump said yesterday “we want action, not talk,” declaring that Mexico could “solve the border crisis in one day if they so desired.”

Source: Milenio (sp) 

Mexico City schools to allow boys to wear skirts, girls to wear pants

0
A student models the new 'neutral uniform' at a Mexico City ceremony today.
A student models the new 'neutral uniform' at a ceremony today.

Students in Mexico City will have a new dress code, permitting boys to wear skirts and girls to wear pants, Mayor Claudia Sheinbaum announced today.

The school uniforms will remain the same but students may choose the uniform they prefer to wear.

Sheinbaum said the city released the new guidelines in an effort to promote equity and equality.

“We are announcing something very simple but for us very transcendent. I think the times have passed in which girls have to wear a skirt and boys have to wear pants,” she said.

Schools in Mexico City will receive a notice of the new guidelines on Monday, said federal Education Secretary Esteban Moctezuma Barragán, who praised the mayor and President López Obrador.

“To have a president as sensitive as Andrés Manuel López Obrador, and a mayor as sensitive as Claudia Sheinbaum is something that ought to be valued and recognized,” he said, expressing the hope that more states will will adopt the new “neutral uniform.”

Source: El Universal (sp)

Morena party wins governors’ races in Puebla, Baja California

0
Election winners Barbosa, left, and Bonilla.
Election winners Barbosa, left, and Bonilla.

Sunday was a good day for the ruling Morena party, winning the governors’ seats in two states previously held by the conservative National Action Party (PAN).

In Baja California, which has been governed by PAN for 30 years, Morena candidate Jaime Bonilla Valdez won 50% of the votes, according to preliminary results, crushing PAN candidate Óscar Vega Marín, who came in second place with 23%.

In Puebla, preliminary results indicate that Morena’s Miguel Barbosa won 43% of the votes to become the state’s next governor, beating out PAN’s Enrique Cárdenas, who won 34%.

In a press conference on Monday, Cárdenas conceded the election to Barbosa while criticizing irregularities in the electoral process and lamenting the low turnout, which he said was around 33%.

Barbosa had run for governor of Puebla in 2018, narrowly losing to PAN’s Marta Erika Alonso in a highly contested election that was plagued by irregularities. However, Alonso was killed in a helicopter crash less than two weeks after taking office, triggering Sunday’s special election.

Morena also took control of 11 of the 15 municipalities in Quintana Roo, while PAN won the most municipal governments in Tamaulipas, Aguascalientes and Durango.

Electoral crimes prosecutor José Agustín Ortiz Pinchetti said his office received 68 reports of electoral crimes over the course of the election, all but three of which proved to be false.

In a press conference Sunday night, Ortiz said that people who make false reports of electoral crimes should be punished.

“I think it’s important that the election law be changed to create serious punishments for this kind of manipulation, because it wastes an enormous amount of our time, energy and resources,” he said.

Ortiz said that overall, he considers Sunday’s elections to have been a success because there were no arrests and no violence.

“And that’s no small feat, because elections in Mexico used to be stained with blood,” he said.

Source: El Universal (sp), La Jornada (sp), El Financiero (sp)

Taxis shut down major Mexico City thoroughfares in ride-sharing protest

0
A cluster of taxis in Mexico City on Monday.
A cluster of taxis in Mexico City on Monday.

Taxi drivers began blocking streets across Mexico City on Monday morning, protesting what they say is unfair competition from ride-sharing services like Uber, Cabify and Didi.

Taxis started congregating in the zócalo around 6:30am, while roadblocks started going up at 10:00am and were expected to remain until noon. The city government said affected thoroughfares will include access points to the capital, such as the México-Pachuca, México-Toluca, México-Querétaro and México-Cuernavaca highways.

Members the National Movement of Taxi Drivers (MNT) are also suspending service in various municipalities in the state of México.

The drivers complain that inconsistent regulation creates an uneven playing field for them to compete with ride-sharing, and want more robust regulation of their competitors.

Mexico City MNT leader Ignacio Rodríguez Mejía told El Universal that taxi drivers have to pay fees and fulfill requirements that do not apply to drivers working with ride-sharing applications.

“The application drivers have all year to get their license, and it’s free,” he said. “But the taxi drivers have to pay, and if they don’t, they can get fined up to 10,000 pesos (US $506).”

According to the MNT, taxi drivers need to pay 713 pesos for a permit, 1,635 pesos for an evaluation and 2,565 pesos for a safety course, all fees that ride-sharing drivers do not pay.

Rodríguez added that taxis must be painted a certain way, which can cost around 2,500 pesos.

In a press conference on Sunday, Mexico City Mobility Secretary Andrés Lajous said that government representatives held more than 150 meetings with taxi drivers’ groups during the month of May to hear their concerns and look for solutions. The Mobility Secretariat (Semovi) has agreed, among other things, to simplify the paperwork that is required for taxis.

Lajous said the government remains open to dialogue.

“We’re not interested in playing politics with them,” he said. “Semovi’s mission is to improve the quality of transportation for people.”

Source: El Universal (sp), Publímetro (sp), La Jornada (sp)

Trump accuses Mexico of ‘abusing US,’ demands action, not talk, on migrants

0
Ebrard speaks at this morning's press conference in Washington.
Ebrard speaks at this morning's press conference in Washington.

Another day, another Twitter tirade by the United States president to malign Mexico.

Three days after announcing that he was placing a 5% tariff on all goods from Mexico to pressure the country to do more to stop the movement of undocumented migrants across its northern border, Donald Trump yesterday labelled Mexico “an abuser of the United States” and declared that “we want action, not talk” to solve the “border crisis.”

Referring to the contingent of Mexican officials led by Foreign Secretary Marcelo Ebrard that has traveled to Washington to meet with United States representatives this week, Trump wrote:

“Mexico is sending a big delegation to talk about the border. Problem is, they’ve been ‘talking’ for 25 years. We want action, not talk. They could solve the border crisis in one day if they so desired. Otherwise, our companies and jobs are coming back to the USA!”

The U.S. president sent a similar message in an earlier two-part tweet.

“People have been saying for years that we should talk to Mexico. The problem is that Mexico is an ‘abuser’ of the United States, taking but never giving. It has been this way for decades. Either they stop the invasion of our country by drug dealers, cartels, human traffickers . . . coyotes and illegal immigrants, which they can do very easily, or our many companies and jobs that have been foolishly allowed to move south of the border will be brought back into the United States through taxation (tariffs). America has had enough!”

Trump then turned his ire to another of his favored punching bags.

“The wall is under construction and moving along quickly, despite all of the radical liberal Democrat lawsuits. What are they thinking as our country is invaded by so many people (illegals) and things (drugs) that we do not want. Make America Great Again!”

Facing his biggest foreign policy test since taking office six months ago, President López Obrador yesterday chose to take a diplomatic path to respond.

“The government of Mexico is a friend of the government of the United States. The president of Mexico wants to continue to be a friend of President Trump. Mexicans are friends of the United States people. To them I say from Paraíso, [Tabasco]: Let us vow that nothing or nobody will divide our beautiful and sacred friendship,” he wrote on Twitter.

López Obrador said he didn’t want confrontation and does not believe in “a tooth for a tooth” and “an eye for an eye.”

López Obrador speaking in Tabasco yesterday, where he offered a message of friendship to the US.
López Obrador speaking in Tabasco yesterday, where he offered a message of friendship to the US.

Although he told Trump in a letter last week that Mexico was doing all it can to “avoid” the flow of migrants through Mexico he suggested on Saturday that migration controls could be tightened further, adding that he expected “good results” from this week’s bilateral talks.

“The main thing is to report on what we’re already doing on the migration issue, and if it’s necessary to reinforce these measures without violating human rights, we could be prepared to reach that deal,” López Obrador said.

Mexican officials are expected to present statistics in Washington that show that arrests and deportations of migrants in Mexico have increased in recent months.

However, counteracting those statistics is United States data that shows that arrests of undocumented migrants in the U.S. surged to over 90,000 in both March and April.

Still, López Obrador stressed that “we’re not going to get into a trade war, a war of tariffs and of taxes.”

If the United States goes ahead with the application of the new tariffs, the president said that his government has a “plan” although he didn’t provide any details.

But he did say that Mexico reserved the right to seek international legal arbitration to solve the dispute.

Some business groups, among them Mexico’s leading farm lobby, urged the government to retaliate against any tariffs imposed by Trump, as occurred last year when the United States implemented duties on steel and aluminum.

The threat of the new universal tariff quickly caused stocks, oil prices and the peso to fall, and there is speculation that the tariffs could derail the ratification process for the new North American trade deal.

Source: Milenio (sp), Reuters (en) 

Guerrero farmers free soldiers, police after fertilizer guarantee

0
Soldiers, police and farmers in Heliodoro Castillo.
Soldiers, police and farmers in Heliodoro Castillo.

The farmers who detained 50 soldiers and police officers on Friday in Heliodoro Castillo, Guerrero, released their captives on Saturday after meeting with state and federal authorities.

On Saturday afternoon, representatives of the farmers’ group traveled to Acapulco to meet with Governor Héctor Astudillo and federal super-delegate Pablo Almícar Sandoval. Both promised the farmers that distribution of fertilizer, which the farmers had been demanding, will begin on Monday.

“There’s fertilizer in Guerrero already, it’s in warehouses, and we are asking for some patience so we can plan the distribution,” Almícar said. “We’ve already published the list of who’s going to receive it, first we’re going to distribute to the Sierra and Montaña regions, and then the rest of the state.”

Astudillo told Televisa that the delay in distribution was due to changes in the new government.

“The truth is that I would have preferred the distribution to have started a month ago or more,” he said. “I understand that these new rules, because they are innovative, are creating delays.”

The fertilizer will be used on more than 400,000 hectares of farmland across the state.

The standoff began on Friday when around 400 farmers surrounded an military barracks, trapping 30 soldiers and 20 state police officers inside. The farmers demanded that the government follow through on promises to distribute fertilizer to their communities. They also demanded the construction of schools and health clinics.

They also complained that the new government is asking them to stop growing opium poppies, but is cutting agricultural subsidies like Procampo.

Source: Reforma (sp), Televisa (sp), Eje Central (sp)