Sunday, August 3, 2025

Guided by tradition, Chiapas coffee growers envision their industry’s future

0
Coffee tasting in Chiapas
Tour participant Manoj Shrestha gets a whiff of sustainably grown coffee at Cafe Nueva Maravilla.

“We’ve won empty space and made paths for walking,” says Jorge Cravioto as he eyes the ever-encroaching forest that surrounds him.

It’s a delicate balance: protecting the fast-growing bamboo, the year-round crickets and the nesting ground of dozens of tropical birds while building a coffee plantation and hotel for visitors.

His project, Finca Brasil, is tucked into the mountains of southeastern Chiapas, right along the Guatemalan border, and while the coffee business here is ancient tradition, this plantation has a futuristic vision for the region’s coffee industry.

Finca Brasil has become a standout example of local coffee farming because of Cravioto and his wife Magda’s commitment to agroforestry, a system of production that harmoniously incorporates cash crops — in their case, coffee — into the surrounding natural landscape. As part of that production system, they grow other flora that they can sell for a profit – things like fruit trees or hardwood trees to be sold for lumber. The system has a lot of benefits, everything from increasing biodiversity to reducing the risk of erosion, and it stands in opposition to conventional commercial coffee production, where land is cleared so coffee bushes can be planted in direct sunlight.

“The main product of this region is coffee,” Cravioto says, “but the price of coffee is suddenly high and then super low, and it’s never enough for the families to live on,” says Carvioto. “The model of Finca Brasil is to grow coffee but also to grow other things.”

Elias Morales Chiapas coffee grower
Elías Morales shows the organic compost around his trees that he grows to diversify the soil and prevent erosion.

However, he quickly adds, “If all I wanted from the coffee was money, I would plant in the direct sun like everyone else.”

Instead, he insists, he and Magda see Finca Brasil as a long-term project that will allow them to make their own small contribution to the future of the planet.

“We need to agree that climate change is real,” he says. “If we don’t protect these spaces, what will we leave for future generations?”

The Craviotos are just one pair of producers in a 20-member coffee collective in Sierra Mariscal,  a seven-municipality coffee-growing region on Chiapas’ southernmost border.

Working together, the collective members are developing and promoting a gourmet coffee route here, one that will bring outsiders in to taste the beans, experience the land, and hopefully buy directly from producers.

Finca Brasil, because of its facilities – their coffee-growing land encircles a rustic eight-room hotel and colorful gardens – has been chosen as one of the bases for exploring this new coffee route.

But if Finca Brasil demonstrates the first step in excellent coffee – growing and harvesting sustainably – Cafe Nueva Maravilla, run by Elías Morales and his wife Wendy, showcases the next.

“My father was a coffee producer, and from the time I was very young, I was involved in production,” says Morales, a quiet man with an easy smile. He opened Nueva Maravilla with his wife a year ago in order to spotlight the area’s highest quality coffee from a wide range of altitudes. He started toasting his own beans 10 years ago and now works with his neighbors to toast theirs.

“[The] habit we had before — me as well — was that you grow the coffee and you sell all of it that’s good and you’re left with the bad. We don’t do that now; we are drinking good coffee and trying to teach people about drinking good coffee.”

Instead of selling all their best coffee to intermediaries, they are now saving some of it, not only for their own consumption but also to sell in their cafe and to offer to visitors that find their way to this 600-person community in the Chiapas mountains. The hope is to develop direct contact with buyers, which they hope will translate into higher prices for the producers – who would make pennies on the dollar using the intermediaries.

“Someone can come and say, ‘I want this coffee from 1,200 meters … I want this one from 1,400 …’,” Morales says. “People say that high-altitude coffees are very acidic, but we can always do a combination of the beans: one that’s 1,600 meters with another that’s 1,000 meters. So in the end, it’s not too acidic, nor is it too mellow.”

He’s been learning this precision alchemy as the collective has worked to produce select coffee – using the term to describe a kind of coffee where everything from the planting of the seeds to the pouring of the finished product has been cared for.

coffee
Members produce coffee where everything from the planting of the seeds to the pouring of the brew has been cared for.

“Now I can grab a handful of beans and just by smelling them determine how the final cup will be,” Morales says proudly.

Like Finca Brasil, he is also using agroforestry techniques and has noticed the difference.

“When the hurricanes passed through, people who had been cutting down their trees suffered a lot of damage [to their crop], but we were fine because the trees helped to keep the roots in the ground,” he says.

Samuel Mendoza, another collective member, runs through a list of characteristics that can be used to describe a specific brew. Mendoza has become an official coffee taster, a skill as complex as being a sommelier or tequilier.

He walks a group of visitors through an extensive but down-to-earth tasting at Cafe Nueva Maravilla, showing them how to gently scoop the grinds that settle on the surface of the coffee, how to slurp from their spoons to disperse its taste throughout and what changes they will notice as the coffee cools from its original 198 F – the officially agreed upon correct temperature for coffee tasting.

“The specialty coffee sector is very rigid in terms of price and sustainability,” says Mendoza, “We want to create added value in order to increase the prices we can get for our coffee. We want to build more cafes like this one, develop the region’s coffee route, and make our coffee more visible.”

Remote and isolated, the coffee communities of Sierra Mariscal are not easy destinations for the average traveler. Mendoza and his business partner have been integral to bringing visitors to experience the coffee route via their local tour company, Travis Tours. They are also working with local authorities to improve roads and encourage investment in tourism infrastructure.

While there is still a long way to go, the collective members have already implemented important new techniques into their coffee production and are learning to value in a new way the product that their families have grown for generations.

“Some say that the best coffee is high-altitude coffee, but the best coffee is one that is cared for from the very beginning to the very end,” says Cravioto.

Lydia Carey is a regular contributor to Mexico News Daily.

Mexican director’s film Nightmare Alley earns 4 Oscar nominations

0
nightmare alley

A film by a Mexican director is competing on four fronts at this year’s Academy Awards.

Guillermo del Toro’s Nightmare Alley was nominated for best picture, best cinematography, best costume design and best production design.

The 150-minute psychological thriller tells the story of a carnival worker who takes a big risk to boost his career.

It is based on the 1946 novel of the same name by William Lindsay Gresham and stars Bradley Cooper and Cate Blanchett.

Critics gave the movie an 80% approval on ratings site Rotten Tomatoes, while 68% of public reviewers offered it the thumbs up.

NIGHTMARE ALLEY | Official Trailer | Searchlight Pictures

Del Toro, a Guadalajara native, won best director for his 2006 film Pan’s Labyrinth and best picture for 2017’s The Shape of Water.

However, he isn’t the only Mexican with a stake in this year’s awards: CODA, a film starring Eugenio Derbez, is nominated for best picture and best adapted screenplay and Carlos López Estrada’s Raya And The Last Dragon is up for best animated feature film.

The film that gained most nominations this year was Power of the Dog, with 12, while Dune received 10 and Belfast and West Side Story were both given seven nominations.

The 94th Academy Awards will take place on March 27 at Hollywood’s Dolby Theatre.

With reports from El Financiero and BBC Mundo

Long COVID survivor wins medals swimming icy waters in Sweden

0
Cold-water swimmer Angélica Cuapio
Cold-water swimmer Angélica Cuapio at the Stockholm Winterswim Open.

A Mexican woman who found that icy water was an effective treatment for her long COVID symptoms won two medals at the 2022 edition of the Swedish winter swimming championships.

Originally from Mexico City, Angélica Cuapio is an immunology researcher at the Karolinska Institute, a medical university in Solna, part of the urban area of the Swedish capital Stockholm.

She was the only Mexican to compete at the Stockholm Winterswim Open – held last Saturday in a lake where ice is cracked to create a swimming course – and placed first in her age category for the 25 meters freestyle, third in the 25 meters breaststroke and fourth in the 4 x 25 meters breaststroke relay.

Water temperature in the lake was 1.9 C.

“… I won first place in the 40 to 44 years category,” Cuapio told the newspaper El Universal in an interview.

Cuapio contracted COVID-19 twice.
Cuapio contracted COVID-19 twice.

She also set a new record for the 25m crawl, finishing in just under 20 seconds.

“I competed because I’m a survivor of the pandemic. I had COVID-19 twice. The most recent time was so severe that I was taken to the emergency department twice,” the scientist said.

She told El Universal that she swims to commemorate those who have died during the pandemic but also to shine a spotlight on those who are living with the effects of long COVID, in which symptoms remain for weeks, months or even longer after the initial infection and illness.

“[I want to] make the existence of these consequences visible, and the important thing is to conduct scientific research about this,” Cuapio said.

“I’m happy with my win and I want to resonate with everyone who has long COVID. This medal and certificate are for all the people who haven’t recovered yet. I want to make it known that long COVID exists, … more research has to be done to find treatments for … this disease,” she said.

Cuapio explained that she suffered extreme fatigue, hair loss, shortness of breath and low spirits, among other symptoms, after her second bout of COVID.

“My medical consultations didn’t find any measurable alteration so the diagnosis was long COVID. As a hobby I started submerging myself in cold water at the end of summer last year and as I kept doing it I noticed that my symptoms began decreasing and some disappeared completely,” she said.

“This hobby became a therapeutic thing, … its impact was so great that I encouraged myself to participate in this competition,” said Cuapio, a graduate of the National Autonomous University Faculty of Medicine who completed postgraduate studies in Europe.

“[Competing] is a great achievement after having the virus twice. I’m grateful … because I feel completely recovered. My triumph is a tribute to the survivors, those who have so-called long COVID, but also to those who didn’t survive in Mexico and the world.”

The researcher has collected anecdotal evidence that hundreds of other people around the world have found cryotherapy, or cold therapy, to be an effect treatment for the symptoms of long COVID.

“[For] some people who had COVID and who continued to have some symptoms, this [treatment] has helped them a lot,” Cuapio said.

With reports from El Universal 

Figure skater makes history by reaching finals at Winter Olympics

0
Mexican skater Donovan Carrillo at Beijing Olympics
Donovan Carrillo flew into the final round of the Olympics men's individual figure skating competition on Tuesday. He's the first Mexican to do so. Los Juegos Olímpicos Twitter

A Mexican figure skater has made history by reaching the finals at the Winter Olympics in Beijing, becoming the first Mexican skater ever to reach the last round at the international competition of the world’s best athletes.

Donovan Carrillo, 22, will join 23 other skaters in the free skate program on Thursday — Wednesday night in North America — despite having spent his life training in Mexico without an ice rink suitable for high-performance athletes.

Medals in the individual figure skating competition are determined by combining the scores achieved in the short program and the free skate program.

Carrillo finished in 19th place in the short program on Tuesday with a personal record score of 79.69 and thus qualified for the free skate program, also known as the long program. It is something none of his compatriots had ever before achieved.

It has been far from plain sailing for the Guadalajara native, who grew up training on ice rinks in shopping malls. At age 12, he moved with his coach to León, Guanajuato, but was still without a professional rink to practice on.

Donovan Carrillo
Carrillo performed in an outfit provided free by Guadalajara designer Edgar Lozano, who used more than 17,000 crystals to make it. Los Juegos Olímpicos Twitter

His family sought sponsors but were rejected. In the end he was supported by friends and relatives, enabling him to travel to Europe to compete.

“Kisses to my family and to all Mexico, dreams really do come true,” he said after the routine.

“One of my first emotions when I finished the short program is that I didn’t want it to end. It was a very special moment, and I was enjoying to the fullest what I love most in life, which is skating … I’m very motivated to give my best in the long program,” Carrillo added.

The figure skater promoted Mexican culture in his performance: the rock ballad Black Magic Woman by Mexican American Carlos Santana, an artist whose music his father played to him as a child, accompanied his acrobatic routine. In the past, he has performed to the music of national treasure Juan Gabriel.

His eye-catching gold and black costume, composed of more than 17,000 crystals, was also of Mexican origin. It was designed by Édgar Lozano, also from Guadalajara, who crafted costumes for Miss Universe 2020, Andrea Meza.

Only three Mexicans have competed in figure skating at the Olympic Games: Ricardo Olavarrieta in 1988 and 1992, Diana Evans in 1988 and Mayda Navarro in 1992.

Donovan Carrillo programa corto 🇲🇽 | Patinaje Artístico Beijing 2022

Donovan Carrillo’s short program performance, skating to the music of Santana.

With reports from El País and Cultura Colectiva

Formal sector job creation breaks a record at more than 900,000

0
construction workers
Construction was one of the sectors that saw the highest growth. deposit photos

The total number of formal sector jobs in Mexico rose by more than 900,000 in the 12-month period to January 31, the biggest increase on record, the Mexican Social Security Institute (IMSS) reported Monday.

Just over 20.76 million workers were registered with IMSS at the end of last month, an increase of 940,768 compared to the end of January 2021.

IMSS said that 86.7% of workers were in permanent positions and the remainder were employed in temporary jobs.

The number of formal sector positions was 142,271 higher than at the end of December. IMSS said it was the biggest December to January increase on record.

It reported that the sectors with the highest annual growth were transport and communications, up 11.3%; construction, up 7.6%; and mining, up 7.3%.

Quintana Roo, Tabasco and Baja California Sur recorded the biggest annual increase in formal sector jobs. Employment growth in all three states was above 14%, IMSS said. Quintana Roo and Baja California Sur are heavily dependent on tourism, which began to recover last year after a sharp pandemic-induced downturn in 2020.

IMSS also reported that the average base salary of formal sector workers was $466 pesos (US $22.60) per day at the end of last month. The annual increase was 8.9%, the highest January to January jobs jump of the past decade.

Meanwhile, the International Labor Organization (ILO) reported that 72% of jobs recovered after the initial lockdown period at the start of the pandemic in 2020 were in the informal sector. The ILO considered data from the middle of 2020 to the third quarter of 2021.

The percentage is higher than several other countries in the region, including Costa Rica, Brazil and Chile.

“Informality is endemic in this region and can be considered a ‘social comorbidity’  in this pandemic,” the ILO said in the executive summary of its 2021 labor overview report for Latin America and the Caribbean.

“In 2019, one in two employed persons was working under informal conditions. At the beginning of the crisis, the informality rate dropped due to the enormous loss of this type of jobs; however, most of the jobs recovered since then have been under informal conditions.”

Mexico News Daily 

AMLO’s economy minister less bullish about growth than her boss

0
Economy Minister Clouthier
Economy Minister Clouthier said her forecast is based on the impact of the omicron variant of COVID-19.

The economy is likely to grow 2.6% in 2022, the economy minister said on Monday, in stark contrast to President López Obrador’s much more positive forecast last Wednesday.

Tatiana Clouthier’s prediction is in line with financial experts and the International Monetary Fund (IMF). Experts surveyed by the Bank of México (Banxico) forecast 2.2% growth this year and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) predicted 2.8%.

In response to the IMF and Banxico’s forecasts, the president predicted 5% growth for the next three years. “Five percent [growth for this year] …. the experts and specialists are giving us at most 2.5% and I’m putting forward 5%. I have information and I’m also optimistic … 5% for 2023 and 5% for 2024,” he said.

The last time Mexico achieved two consecutive years of growth over 5% was in 1996-97. Prior to that was in the early 1980s. This year seems a particularly unlikely year to repeat the feat given that the economy entered a technical recession in late 2021.

Clouthier said her lower figure was due to the continued negative impact of the coronavirus omicron variant. “If we remember back a little … the Treasury proposed 4% [growth for 2022]. That was before omicron. Right now, we estimate it could be around 2.5-2.6%,” she said.

Clouthier added that optimism may have inspired the president’s eye-catching prediction. “There are many factors that occur throughout the year that can positively or negatively alter the year. I think the president is betting that positive things will happen.”

The economy achieved 5% growth in 2021. That followed an 8.4% contraction in 2020, while inflation in 2021 soared to 7.36%, the highest level in 21 years.

With reports from Reforma

US special envoy to meet with AMLO on climate, renewable energy

0
US Special Envoy on Climate John Kerry
The US Department of State announced that John Kerry would meet with AMLO to 'accelerate cooperation on the climate crisis.' File photo

The United States special presidential envoy for climate will meet with President López Obrador for the second time in less than four months on Wednesday.

John Kerry will travel to Mexico City “to engage with government counterparts and accelerate cooperation on the climate crisis, including opportunities for expanding renewable power generation, creating a sound investment climate, combating methane pollution, transitioning to zero-emissions transportation and ending deforestation,” the U.S. Department of State said in a media note Monday.

The visit will take place 114 days after the two men traveled to Palenque, Chiapas, to visit a parcel of community land where the federal government’s tree-planting employment program, Sembrando Vida (Sowing Life), is operating.

López Obrador declared at the time that Mexico was an ally of the United States in the fight against climate change.

AMLO with Kerry in Palenque, Chiapas
Kerry was in Palenque, Chiapas, in October, where AMLO showcased the federal government’s Sembrando Vida tree-planting program.

Wednesday’s meeting between the president and the special envoy will occur three weeks after United States Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm visited the Mexican capital and conveyed “real concerns” about Mexico’s proposed electricity reform.

She said in a statement that the planned reform could have a negative impact on U.S. investment in Mexico and “hinder U.S.-Mexico joint efforts on clean energy and climate.”

U.S. senators, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce in Mexico, the European Union’s ambassador to Mexico, U.S. Ambassador Ken Salazar and the Mexican Solar Energy Association have also raised concerns about the planned constitutional change, which would guarantee 54% of the electricity market to the fossil fuel-dependent, state-owned Federal Electricity Commission and get rid of two energy sector regulators.

Kerry’s visit comes as the lower house of Congress analyzes the reform, which would partially reverse the 2013 reform that opened up the nationalized electricity and oil markets to foreign and private companies. A vote is expected as soon as next month.

Salazar, a former U.S. senator and secretary of the interior who succeeded Christopher Landau as ambassador last September, changed his tune last week, saying that energy reform was in fact necessary although his comments were somewhat ambiguous.

His comment was met with appreciation from López Obrador, who offered the words “Muy bien, Ken” (very good, Ken) in response.

Ken Salazar and President Lopez Obrador.
US Ambassador to Mexico Ken Salazar’s tweet last week supporting energy reform for Mexico sparked criticism. File photo

Mary Anastasia O’Grady, a columnist and editorial board member for The Wall Street Journal, rebuked Salazar for “contradicting the Biden administration as … [he] finished a visit to Mexico’s Chamber of Deputies.”

“There’s no way to overstate Mr. Salazar’s bad judgment,” she wrote in a column published under the headline “A U.S. Ambassador Takes Mexico’s Side.”

“… The reforms directly contravene the country’s commitments under the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement [USMCA] to guarantee open, competitive markets and equal treatment of all parties, foreign and domestic,” O’Grady said.

She noted that Salazar took to Twitter to “walk back his comment,” writing that he continued to “trust that Mexico will fulfill its commitments under USMCA as it considers changes to the energy sector” – but charged that “the damage was done.”

The columnist was critical of a range of provisions in the proposed reform and charged that “capital would dry up” because equal treatment under the law for investors would no longer be guaranteed.

“But that’s no matter for AMLO. His goal is to consolidate power so the government can centrally plan and control Mexico’s energy industry and the economy that relies on it,” O’Grady wrote.

Mary Anastasia O'Grady
Wall Street Journal columnist Mary Anastasia O’Grady.

“… Mexico is already violating the rights of American energy companies,” she said, citing the seizure of U.S.-owned fuel storage terminals among other examples.

“… Obviously, Mr. Salazar hasn’t been reading the mail. Since the fall, Washington lawmakers on both sides of the aisle have been asking the [U.S.] administration for help,” O’Grady said.

“… Mexico is engaged in an assault on the North American energy market, a key component of the USMCA and of development on both sides of the border. The U.S. has an obligation to call for formal consultations. Mexico’s most important trading partner needs to understand where AMLO is headed with his energy reforms and related discrimination already taking place,” she wrote.

“It ought to advise the Mexican president that violations of the trade agreement will have consequences, including painful retaliation. Meantime, Joe Biden should find his former Senate colleague a new job,” O’Grady concluded.

With reports from Reforma 

Mexican fishboats barred from US ports for illegal fishing of red snapper

0

Mexican fishboats are now prohibited from entering United States ports in the Gulf of Mexico after a U.S. government ban took effect Monday due to illegal fishing in U.S. waters.

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), a U.S. government agency, said in a ruling in early January that Mexican vessels would be barred from entering those ports starting February 7.

According to the U.S. government, Mexico hasn’t done enough to stop Mexican boats’ illegal fishing of red snapper.

“Mexican boats frequently use prohibited long lines or nets to haul in snapper in U.S. waters. Such nets and lines can indiscriminately trap marine life,” the Associated Press reported.

The number of detected illegal fishing incursions into U.S. waters reached 138 in 2020, double the figure of 2019.

In a report submitted to the U.S. Congress last August, NOAA said that Mexico had made some progress on combatting the practice but not enough.

The apprehension of repeat offenders by the U.S. Coast Guard is common, with some Mexican fishermen being detected in U.S. waters more than 20 times over the past eight years. More than 100 recidivists were caught between October 2019 and September 2020, and an additional 84 were apprehended in the following six months.

NOAA said the incursions must decrease before the ban will be lifted. The agency said the United States is committed to working with Mexico to combat the problem.

Economy Minister Tatiana Clouthier said Monday that Mexican authorities would do what they could to have the ban lifted.

“In a few days we’ll have a meeting with environmental organizations to see how we’re going to do it,” she said in an interview.

Agriculture and fishing authorities said Monday they are engaging in discussions with northern Gulf coast fishermen about the illegal fishing issue.

Foreign Affairs Minister Marcelo Ebrard claimed that Mexican boats were entering U.S. waters by mistake, asserting that “sometimes it’s hard to determine the exact line” between the two countries’ territorial waters. “It’s not something intentional,” he said.

However, AP noted that critics say that it’s more likely that Mexican boats are following fish into U.S. waters rather than repeatedly making the same navigational mistake.

Renata Terrazas, Mexico vice president of non-profit ocean conservation organization Oceana, said the ban will have multiple adverse impacts.

“The most immediate is … [on] boats that go to United States ports to buy gasoline or sell fish,” she said, including those that abide by the law.

Oceana has called on the Mexican government to implement traceability regulations that would facilitate the provision of information about the processes that seafood goes through “from the boat to the plate” and thus give greater certainty about where fish are caught. However, an initiative to that end has been stalled at the National Aquaculture and Fisheries Commission for almost a year, according to the NGO.

“If they activate the regulations, certainty that we’re taking the [illegal fishing] problem seriously could be provided to the United States,” Terrazas said.

“Fishing in Mexico seems to be a 19th century activity. It needs to meet the standards of international markets, of consumers who are increasingly looking for more sustainable products,” she said.

The United States last year suspended Mexico’s certification to export wild-caught shrimp to the U.S. due to inadequate sea turtle protection measures, but the suspension ended six months later in October.

With reports from El País and AP

Meet Niki, the newest recruit to Mexico City’s canine unit

0
Niki shepherd recruit canine unit CDMX
The canine unit can't expect much of Niki yet other than play, but she already feels part of the team, trainer Lucía San Juan said.

A new four-legged recruit has joined Mexico City’s security forces.

Niki, a four-month-old Belgian shepherd, is the newest addition to the canine unit at Mexico City’s Citizen Security Ministry (SSC).

The pup is being trained for search and rescue tasks in natural disasters, such as earthquakes.

Some of her 18 furry companions will instead be trained to detect explosives or drugs.

A trainer at the canine unit, Lucía San Juan, said Niki already felt part of the team.

“She’s a very active puppy. She’s in very good hands … we will give her family warmth and training that prepares her to help citizens.”

She added that she was already well acquainted with Niki.

“If I go out, she goes out with me. If I stay inside, she stays by my side. In some obedience training, we work together constantly,” San Juan explained.

“Or even when I go on break, she goes with me. The idea is to live together as a family … What I can tell citizens is that we learn to understand the animals. Since we are part of the same family, the best thing we can do is take care of them and love them,” she said.

San Juan added that progress would be slow with Niki. “We have already started her training. However, as she is still a four-month-old dog, we cannot demand much more than strokes and games.”

The canine unit’s first task is to help Niki conquer her fear of heights.

An SSC official, Daniel Álvarez, said it was vital to train the pups from a young age. “Initially, we recruit all the dogs when they are puppies. We socialize them in the environment, so that in the future when they go out on public duties they are clued in and can do a good job,” he said.

With reports from Milenio

Mexico City government criticized for providing ivermectin to treat COVID

0
Medical kits
Medical kits containing ivermectin were handed out to COVID patients in the capital.

The Mexico City government has become engulfed in scandal due to its distribution of the anti-parasitic drug ivermectin to people who tested positive for COVID-19, its alleged completion of an unauthorized study on the medication’s efficacy and its publication of a paper detailing its supposed benefits.

The government spent just under 29.3 million pesos (US $1.4 million) to buy 293,000 boxes of the drug – usually used to treat conditions caused by intestinal parasites, head lice, scabies and other skin infections – as well as significant quantities of aspirin and azithromycin, an antibiotic.

The medications are not approved by the federal government or the World Health Organization for the treatment of COVID but the administration led by Mayor Claudia Sheinbaum nevertheless distributed them to some 200,000 people who tested positive, according to an investigation by the news website Animal Político.

The drugs were distributed in medical kits handed out at Mexico City testing stations starting in December 2020. They continued to be distributed until September 2021.

The Mexico City government as well as the federally-run Mexican Social Security Institute (IMSS) announced last year that they had carried out a “quasi experimental” analysis that found that people who received the ivermectin distributed in the capital were 68% less likely to develop serious symptoms that required treatment in hospital.

“… The medical kit was a significant factor in the reduction of hospital admissions and of course possible deaths,” José Antonio Peña Merino, the head of the Mexico City government’s Digital Agency for Public Innovation (ADIP), said in May 2021.

Peña, Mexico City Health Minister Olivia López and other officials co-authored a paper detailing the results of the analysis that was published on the website SocArXic, which describes itself as an open archive of the social sciences.

Ivermectin and the odds of hospitalization due to COVID-19: evidence from a quasi-experimental analysis based on a public intervention in Mexico City was downloaded more than 11,000 times and was among SocArXic’s “most-read papers of the past year,” the website’s director, American sociologist Philip N. Cohen, said in a statement last Friday.

He announced that SocArXiv’s steering committee had decided to withdraw the paper due to various concerns about it, among which was that it was “spreading misinformation [and] promoting an unproved medical treatment in the midst of a global pandemic.”

Cohen noted that SocArXiv had previously written about the paper, saying that “depending on which critique you prefer, the paper is either very poor quality or else deliberately false and misleading.”

He said the paper had received more attention as the result of a report published by Animal Político last Tuesday.

covid

“In response, University of California-San Diego sociology professor Juan Pablo Pardo-Guerra posted an appeal to SocArXiv asking us to remove the ‘deeply problematic and unethical’ paper and ban its authors from our platform. The appeal, in a widely shared Twitter thread, argued that the authors, through their agency dispensing the medication, unethically recruited experimental subjects, apparently without informed consent, and thus the study is an unethical study; they did not declare a conflict of interest, although they are employees of agencies that carried out the policy,” Cohen wrote.

“… It is clear from the record of authoritative statements by global and national public health agencies that, at present, ivermectin should not be used as a treatment or preventative for COVID-19 outside of carefully controlled clinical studies, which this clearly was not,” he said.

Experts who spoke with the newspaper El Universal said the Mexico City government should offer a public apology for distributing ivermectin and completing an unauthorized study. One doctor asserted that the officials responsible should resign.

Omar Yaxmehen Bello Chavolla, a medical researcher and academic at the National Autonomous University, stressed that ivermectin has not been approved for the treatment of COVID-19. He noted that there are studies that suggest that a very high dosage of the drug could work against COVID, but such doses are toxic.

“There’s a lot of misinformation around, and you may have heard that it’s OK to take large doses of ivermectin. It is not OK,” the United States Food and Drug Administration says on its website.

From an ethical point of view, the government’s actions “left a lot to be desired,” Bello said, noting that there is no evidence that the people who received the medical kits were informed they would be part of a study.

“What we would expect is [for the government] to say: ‘We recant from this publication and are aware of the ethical implications; the case will be reviewed to define responsibilities …,’” he said.

Carlos Sanders-Velez, a medical doctor and scientist, said everyone involved in the ivermectin saga should resign immediately given that it may have caused harm. It’s a medication that can cause serious adverse effects, he said.

Xavier Tello, a health policy analyst, said the distribution of a drug not approved for treating COVID is “one of the biggest mistakes” the Mexico City government has made.

The Mexico City Health Ministry (Sedesa) defended the distribution of ivermectin to ambulatory COVID-19 patients, issuing a statement on Saturday that said the medication is “safe, cheap [and] without adverse effects in controlled quantities.”

“This medication is approved in the country. It has been used to treat a range of parasite infections and other diseases with a lot of success. … [The distribution of ivermectin to COVID-19 patients] was not an experiment as some media outlets have deceitfully [said],” the ministry said.

Sedesa said it stopped distributing the drug in September after the federal government published a COVID clinical guide advising against its use.

IMSS – a federal agency – also said the use of ivermectin in Mexico City was not part of an experiment. It said the drug can be beneficial to COVID patients and the risk in using it is “practically non-existent.”

Via a statement issued by its medical benefits division, the agency reiterated the findings of the paper published on SocArXic, saying that the use of ivermectin – as well as its strategy of monitoring COVID patients being treated at home – reduced the need for people to be admitted to hospital.

“The medication was included in [medical] kits for ambulatory patients prior to medical evaluation and with complementary instructions … and monitoring of symptoms via telephone. At no time were experiments undertaken,” IMSS said.

“… The use of ivermectin was recommended in patients with a diagnosis of mild or moderate … pneumonia,” it said.

“… The recommendation came from a group of expert pulmonologists and infectious disease doctors who took into account the stage of the pandemic, which had claimed the lives of many Mexicans,” IMSS said.

“The vaccination program was only just beginning, for which reason its use was considered in the face of an emergency health situation, taking into account the lack, at that time, of any treatment with proven efficacy,” it said.

President López Obrador and Deputy Health Minister Hugo López-Gatell – the government’s coronavirus czar – weighed in on the controversy on Tuesday, with both men defending the Mexico City government.

The former said the journalistic investigation was part of a “campaign of attacks” on the government run by “the conservative bloc and its mouthpieces.”

“… Two magazines that received money from the previous government are involved, … one is Nexos and the other is Animal Político,” López Obrador said.

López-Gatell echoed the claim that no ivermectin experiment was undertaken and asserted there had been a persistent distortion of the truth with regard to the matter. “There was no experiment as many media outlets say,” he declared.

With reports from Animal Político, El Universal and Milenio