US indictment of Sinaloan governor lacks proof, Sheinbaum says: Thursday’s mañanera recapped

Sheinbaum’s mañanera in 60 seconds

  • ⚖️ Rocha indictment: ‘Where’s the proof?’ Sheinbaum questioned the U.S. drug trafficking charges against Sinaloa Governor Rubén Rocha Moya, demanding “conclusive evidence” and calling the indictment’s key exhibit — a handwritten list of bribe amounts — little more than a sheet of paper with names and figures.

  • 🇲🇽 Sovereignty over extradition: The president ruled nothing in or out on Rocha’s potential extradition, insisting any action must follow Mexican law and the Constitution. She warned that her government won’t allow “any foreign government to decide the future of the people of Mexico.”

  • 🤔 Political motives alleged: Sheinbaum stopped short of flatly accusing Washington of bad faith, but asked: “If the proof isn’t there, what is the motivation?” She also highlighted that U.S. authorities have never previously sought an extradition order for a sitting Mexican governor.

  • 📞 Presidential call to Rocha: Sheinbaum confirmed she spoke with the governor after the indictment dropped, telling him: “If there is nothing [illegal], there is nothing to fear.” She said that no one, not a regular citizen nor a governor, can be arrested without proof.

Why today’s mañanera matters

As expected, the key focus of President Sheinbaum’s Thursday morning press conference was the Wednesday revelation that Sinaloa Governor Rubén Rocha Moya and nine other current and former Sinaloa-based officials are accused of drug trafficking and related weapons offenses in the United States. U.S. prosecutors accuse the 10 defendants — including a Morena party senator and the mayor of Culiacán — of colluding with the Sinaloa Cartel, especially the “Los Chapitos” faction led by sons of convicted drug lord Joaquín “El Chapo” Guzmán.

Sheinbaum began her press conference by reading out a statement detailing her government’s position regarding the accusations.

Sheinbaum refuses to hand over Sinaloa Gov. Rocha without ‘irrefutable’ evidence

She said that her government won’t provide cover for anyone who has committed a crime, but asserted that without “clear proof” the objective of the U.S. charges is “political.”

The president and Rocha belong to the same political movement — the “Fourth Transformation” project, which was founded by former President Andrés Manuel López Obrador and is supported by the ruling Morena party. Thus, the accusations against the governor are damaging for the president as well.

Indeed, Rocha himself asserted on Wednesday that “this attack” from U.S. authorities “isn’t solely against me, but also against the movement of the Fourth Transformation, its emblematic leaders and the Mexican women and men who represent that cause.” He “categorically” denied the charges against him.

During today’s mañanera, Sheinbaum returned to the same line on various occasions, asserting time and time again that there is no hard proof against Rocha and his co-defendants. Still, a U.S. indictment carries weight, and this one in particular is a major headache and challenge for the president. Its unsealing comes at a time when the Mexico-U.S. relationship is already strained due to the CIA’s alleged participation in a drug lab raid in Chihuahua without the knowledge or approval of the Mexican government.

Sheinbaum asserts there is a lack of ‘proof’ in US indictment

Asked what “value” her government is giving to the U.S. accusations against Rocha, Sheinbaum responded that “any” accusation has to be supported by “conclusive evidence.”

“We have to ask for the proof,” she said.

“… When we say proof, … [we mean] proof, not just what a person says. There has to be conclusive evidence in accordance with Mexican legislation,” Sheinbaum said, referring to the standard that must be met in order for a person to be arrested.

She subsequently displayed and referred to a superseding indictment that the U.S. Justice Department published online on Wednesday, which sets out the charges against Rocha and the nine other defendants.

“This is the proof,” Sheinbaum said, referring to a handwritten list of amounts in pesos that Sinaloa-based law enforcement officials allegedly received in bribes from the “Los Chapitos” faction of the Sinaloa Cartel.

“… It’s striking, don’t you think? This is the only document that they put in this text as a document of proof,” she said.

“Juanito, 30,000 pesos,” Sheinbaum said, reading from the document included in the indictment. “… It’s a sheet of paper,” she added.

Sheinbuam shares a screen showing the U.S. indictment against Rocha Moya at her Thursday press conference.
President Sheinbaum dismissed evidence presented in the U.S. indictment against Sinaloa Gov. Rubén Rocha Moya as insufficient to justify his arrest. (Mario Jasso / Cuartoscuro.com)

Sheinbaum: ‘We don’t protect anyone’

Sheinbaum asserted that her government doesn’t protect anyone who has committed a crime.

However, she stressed that “there has to be proof” and “documents” that prove a person’s guilt in order for authorities to take action against him or her.

Referring to the U.S. accusations against Rocha and the other defendants, Sheinbaum said:

“If that proof is not there, the question is what is the motivation?”

Asked whether she saw “electoral overtones” in the U.S. accusations, Sheinbaum responded:

“We’re going to wait. … This had never happened before. Never in history had a [U.S.] prosecutor’s office or the U.S. Department of Justice requested an extradition order for a sitting governor or sitting mayor or sitting senator. So what has to be done? … We have to adhere to the law, the Constitution, the treaties, but always under Mexican law. So first the Federal Attorney General’s Office has to ask for the proof. What proof do they have? Because so far there is a document [detailing] what some witnesses say, witnesses whose identities we don’t know.”

Sheinbaum: ‘We’re not going to allow any foreign government to decide the future of the people of Mexico’

Sheinbaum declared that her administration won’t allow “any foreign government to decide the future of the people of Mexico.”

“Article 39 of the Constitution is very clear — sovereignty comes from the people,” she said.

Sheinbaum said that there are “two issues” at play with respect to the U.S. accusations.

One is “defense of sovereignty” and the other is “the rule of law,” she said.

“But the rule of law has to mean proof” against those accused, Sheinbaum said.

Sheinbaum says she is not aware of any accusations against other politicians 

Asked whether she had any knowledge of pending U.S. accusations against Mexican officials not named in the indictment unsealed on Wednesday, Sheinbaum said she did not.

“Until now, the U.S. government, through its embassy, has not provided information additional to this,” she said.

Sheinbaum: ‘What would other countries think’ if Mexico investigated their politicians?

Turning her attention to the topic of “interference,” Sheinbaum created a hypothetical situation.

If the Federal Attorney General’s Office “was investigating [foreign] governors, mayors and senators, … what would other countries think?” she asked.

“… What would the people of a country think if the Federal Attorney General’s Office did an investigation and presented an extradition order for a sitting governor of that country?”

Will Rocha be extradited to the US?  

A reporter asked the president whether she would consider the extradition of Rocha to the United States or whether she could rule out such an eventuality.

“First and foremost, it’s about proof,” Sheinbaum said.

“… The Attorney General’s Office has to act based on our legislation and our jurisdiction,” she said.

Sheinbaum comments on her conversation with Rocha  

Sheinbaum said that she spoke to Rocha on Wednesday after the U.S. Justice Department announced the charges against him.

“I said to him what I say here. If there is nothing [illegal], there is nothing to fear, nothing,” she said.

“There has to be proof. Put yourself in the place of a citizen who doesn’t have an elected position. An arrest without proof? No, right? It’s the same for a governor. In addition there would have to a be a desafuero [removal of political immunity] if any proof against him were to be found,” Sheinbaum said.

Sheinbaum asserts she would act in ‘exactly’ the same way if the US requested the extradition of an opposition governor 

Sheinbaum told reporters that she would act “exactly the same way” if U.S. authorities were seeking the extradition of a PRI, PAN or Citizens Movement Party governor to face charges in the United States.

“Imagine if an extradition request or a provisional arrest request arrived without any proof for a governor of another party. Because they’re from another party am I going to act differently? No,” the president said.

“It’s up to me to defend the Constitution, the laws and sovereignty. The law is for everyone,” Sheinbaum said.

By Mexico News Daily chief staff writer Peter Davies (peter.davies@mexiconewsdaily.com)

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
lascocinas

Interior Ministry confirms public access to Las Cocinas, meeting one of the Punta de Mita protesters’ demands

0
The Nayarit coast's burgeoning fame as an attractive tourist destination has inevitably led to increased development, which has just as inevitably led to protests on environmental and public-access grounds.
oil spill cleanup on Gulf beach

Feb. 6 oil spill continues to impact Gulf of Mexico beaches and marine life

0
The spill has killed at least 22 sea turtles, four dolphins and one manatee, in addition to damaging fish populations, coastal birds (including two pelican deaths), mangroves and reefs, according to media reports.
Sinaloa Governor Rubén Rocha Moya

US charges Sinaloa governor, 9 state officials with drug trafficking

15
Prosecutors in the United States have formally accused Sinaloa Governor Rubén Rocha Moya and nine other current and former Mexican officials of drug trafficking and related weapons offenses, alleging that they colluded with the Sinaloa Cartel.
BETA Version - Powered by Perplexity