Friday, February 21, 2025

Judge suspends clear-cutting on Sections 3-6 of Maya Train

A judge has ordered the total suspension of logging activity in Sections 3 to 6 of the Maya Train route, stretching from Calkiní, Campeche, through Yucatán state to Chetumal, Quintana Roo. 

The affected area forms the majority of the planned railway, as well as almost the entirety of the Caribbean coastal section.

The construction of the train, which will transport both passengers and cargo, is a major infrastructure project, and critics say it risks permanently damaging the fragile ecosystem in the region. (Elizabeth Ruiz/Cuartoscuro)

Yucatán’s First District Court granted the injunction after a petition by a coalition of local environmentalists and civil society organizations, who argued that authorities had failed to obtain necessary permissions for a change of use of forest lands.

The petition was upheld, as the complainants proved they belonged to communities with strong ties to the local ecosystem and were at risk of being negatively affected by the change in land use. 

The victorious coalition included indigenous, farming, urban and coastal communities from all three affected states.

“The removal of forest vegetation is not allowed in areas that are outside the authorizations of change of land use in forest lands,” the resolution states.

An artist's conception of the Maya Train.
The train will link much of southern Mexico, which the government hopes will provide economic support to the traditionally underdeveloped region. (Fonatur)

Mexico’s Environmental Ministry has already issued these authorizations for most of Sections 3–6, but areas remain where work has continued, despite the lack of full authorization. The court found that the ministry’s authorization was insufficient since it did not include a technical study of the potential environmental repercussions of the logging work.

“Continuing with the logging and clearing activities for the construction of the Maya Train megaproject without having obtained authorizations for change of use can cause communities and organizations to suffer an irreparable impact on their right to a healthy environment,” the Mexican Center for Environmental Law (Cemda) said in a statement.

Cemda also called on the judiciary to act with greater diligence regarding the Maya Train, given that “in the face of the suspensions previously issued, the responsible authorities have not complied with the established determinations.”

In January, the First District Court of Mérida issued a temporary injunction against work on Section 5 of the Maya Train, which runs between Cancún and Tulum, in response to complaints about unauthorized changes in land use.

At the time, activist José Urbina pointed out that “forest law says that if you cut down a tree without authorization, you cannot touch the area for 20 years.”

A day after the injunction, however, environmental groups reported via social media that work continued in the area, and called on their supporters to help publicize and ensure enforcement of the ruling. Construction on Section 5 also continued through last year despite several previous injunctions, after the government declared the project a matter of national security. 

The controversial 1,500-km railroad loop was a key campaign promise of President López Obrador, who sees it as vital to the economic development of the Yucatán Peninsula and southern Mexico.

With reports from Reforma and La Jornada

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Roberta Jacobson, Tatiana Clouthier and Jeff Flake, 2025 Future of Mexico Forum participants

2025 Future of Mexico Forum: MND talks migration with Tatiana Clouthier, Jeff Flake, Roberta Jacobson

0
Mexican and U.S. experts discussed deportation, border security and migration at the forum co-hosted by Mexico News Daily earlier this month in Los Cabos.
President Claudia Sheinbaum stands at a table in the national palace press briefing room holding open a portfolio with a sheet of paper on each side that contains the text of proposed reforms to the Mexican constitution.

A reform to protect Mexico’s sovereignty: Thursday’s mañanera recapped

3
At her Thursday press conference, President Sheinbaum announced she'll submit to Congress a constitutional reform proposal aimed at protecting Mexico from foreign interference.
Elderly man in shorts and sandals and no shirt on the shore of a beach in Mexico touching an oarfish in the surf. The iridescent fish is a pellagic type, i.e. very long and reminiscent of an eel.

‘Doomsday fish’ washes ashore near Loreto

0
The deep-water fish's rare appearance on a Baja California Sur beach took the Boise, Idaho, tourist by surprise — even more so when the eel-like fish seemingly refused to leave.