Campeche’s bees, vital for Indigenous bioculture, present their case for legal rights

Mexico’s Supreme Court has agreed to hear a landmark case that could recognize bees as subjects of rights, a move Indigenous communities say is critical to protecting both biodiversity and their own cultural survival.

In an amparo case — a Mexican constitutional injunction used to defend fundamental rights — a group of Maya communities in the southeastern state of Campeche is asking the high court to grant legal standing to melipona bees native to the area.

Hopelchenin Campeche map locator
The Campeche municipality of Hopelchén, located toward the bottom of the map, 93 kilometers due west of the city of Campeche and 174 kilometers south of Mérida, is the state’s most productive beekeeping and agricultural region and home to the communities involved in the rights case. (Google Maps)

The case also asks that Indigenous beekeepers be recognized as the guardians of these stingless honeybees, which are facing mass die-offs linked to deforestation for soy production, heavy pesticide use and climate change.

These hardships have threatened a honey industry that underpins local livelihoods and biocultural heritage, the lawsuit says.

Activists say authorities at all levels have failed to guarantee the constitutional right to a clean and safe environment, or to investigate complaints over habitat destruction and toxic chemicals. 

The lawsuit, taken up last week with eight votes in favor and one against, also challenges regulatory agencies for allegedly ignoring calls to treat bees as rights-bearing entities and Maya communities as their legal representatives.

The communities involved in the case are in the inland municipality of Hopelchén, the state’s most productive beekeeping and agricultural region. 

Soybean cultivation there has expanded rapidly and is directly tied to deforestation and glyphosate-heavy industrial agriculture, with studies noting that the area’s forests are being cleared “at a dizzying rate.”

Justice Irving Espinosa Betanzo said the case “allows us to study the ancestral relationship of the Maya community with bees [and] whether Indigenous communities can be guardians of nature.”

Mexico is home to about 1,900 bee species, including at least 46 native stingless bee species, 19 of which are traditionally managed by Indigenous communities.

The honey and propolis (sometimes called “bee glue”) from the melipona bees — stingless honey-producers native to Mexico and Central America — have shown antioxidant, anti-inflammatory and potential anti-cancer properties in studies of diseases such as diabetes and hypertension.

Mexico’s rights-of-nature debate is also playing out at sea.

Last year, a coalition of organizations filed an amparo on behalf of Gulf of California whales, arguing that the animals have an inalienable right to a safe, livable environment. In that case, a federal judge blocked mega-ship traffic tied to a planned LNG export terminal.

With reports from La Jornada, Wired en Español and UniVerso

3 COMMENTS

Have something to say? Paid Subscribers get all access to make & read comments.
Gabito Ballestero

Singer Gabito Ballesteros detained after his Querétaro show was halted over banned narco-ballads

2
The popular performer of corridos tumbados was arrested after a gun was found in the car he was carried in, which later was proven to be legally licensed. But his show was stopped for including two songs with lyrics deemed to glorify narcos.
President Sheinbaum speaks at the plenary session of the APEC Leaders Meeting on Thursday.

Sheinbaum leaves Shenzhen after a blitz of bilateral meetings at APEC

4
The president called her four-day trip to Shenzhen “very productive and successful,” but said Mexico has no plans for a free trade agreement with China.
pet dog

Congress approves Animal Welfare Law, spelling out pet owners’ legal responsibilities 

3
The bill prohibits animal abuse in the public sphere, such as in circuses advertising and fighting events. But its most relevant action for pet owners is to apply legal sanctions for failure to follow such basic responsibilities as providing food, shelter and water.
BETA Version - Powered by Perplexity